Richmond +14.5
Overall, the numbers of these teams are pretty similar...BOTH teams av'ing 46 I50's per game, Richmond allowing 54, Melbourne 55...
...you'd think that would have changes recently?...well, yes...in Richmond's favour!
The last 5 show Richmond with a semi-respectable 46-51...Melbourne blown out to 46-57!!
Even in last week's win they had 9 less entries than Collingwood...but poor effciency up forward cost the 'Pies...more to the point when O'Brien went down they had no-one to cover Robertson.
The other factor is in the ruck. Richmond have been god-awful in the ruck, but surprisingly, Melbourne have been almost as bad...47-89 effective hitouts for the year...16-48 in their last 5!!! (Richmond 18-41)
As I mentioned earlier, I50's identical...efficiency almost the same...both score about the same (obviously!)...the slight advantage to Melbourne in defense (1.85 to 1.71 overall, and 1.89 to 1.69 in the last 5)...but can a Melbourne forward line minus Nietz take advantage?
Melbourne won in a stinker last year by 18 points...but had 4 less I50's...they managed to hold Richmond to a score just every 2.88 entries, which you'd have to suggest is very unlikely this season.
Melbourne are every bit as bad as Richmond, and I think the price has a bit of "Carlton" about it...2 wins, and suddenly they are a good team??!!
Nope.
Better than Richmond? Maybe....more than 2 goals better? ... can't see it.
Collingwood +15.5
A look at Sydney results so far...
Wins v. WC here (yeah, not bad I guess...but WC have since been poor away from home a lot!)
...Richmond, Brisbane, Melbourne, Port and Doggies...
As I mentioned last week, in the win over Hawthorn, they were statistically smashed...in fact in the last 5 games, Collingwood +4 I50's, Sydney -1...
...now this has to be tempered somewhat by Collingwood's draw too...last 5 have been Carlton, Dogs, Freo, Brisbane, Melbourne...
...but head-to-heads show a good match-up for the 'Pies. Last 4 at this venue have been 2-2, with Sydney wins by just 6 and 1, and a Collingwood win last year by 13 as 2.40 'dogs...
...in fact the av margin between these teams in their last 9 meetings is just 12 ppg!!
Would love Clement to play...can Wakelin, Maxwell and (likely) Cox do the job?...
...the way the Sydney forwards are playing, I'd have to think they might.
Again, in what looks like a very even game, nearly 3 goals will be huge...