Curiosity..Best Players at various positions

[scott]

QB
1. Eil Manning (no other college quarterback can read a defense and make the appropiate adjustments at the line..no bias of course, some talk about his numbers, keep in mind that Ole Miss ran the ball more more than they passed it.)
2. Matt Leinart (even though i agree that the pac-10 is week, he is a great qb)

?)Ben Rothlisberger ( i wish that i could of seen him play a better schedule than the MAC, this way we could see how he performs against teams that actually play defense)

RB
1. Darren Sproles
2. Carnel Williams
3. Kevin Jones

Wr
1. Larry Fitzgerald
2. Rahaun Woods
3. Mike Williams
4. Roy Williams
5.Michael Clayton

TE
1. Ben Troupe ( He is just good)

DL
1. Chad Lavalais
2. Tommy Harris

Lb
1. Tommy Harris
2. Karlos Dansby
3. Derrick Johnson

DB
1. Derrick Strait
2.Kewain Ratliff

Best Coach
1. Nick Saban
2. Bob Stoops
3. Pete Carrol
4 Mark Richt (might change after next year)
Honorable Mention
1. David Cutcliff
2. Urban Myer

117. Mac Brown

 

[Scott4USC]

Nice Job. I agree with your list for the most part. Glad we can agree on something.

Without question, Udeze should have been on your DL list. The guy ended the year #1 sack leader in the nation (including bowl games). The guy is an animal.

Nice WR list, Mike Williams should have been #1 IMO. According to NFL scouts, Williams is the best WR in college football. I agree.

Agree Matt Leinart is #2 but he put up the same #'s against Michigan and Michigan had a top 5 defense and a top secondary in the country. So I guess the Pac 10 is not so weak. Plus the Pac 10 did well in the bowl season. (i do agree it was a down year for the pac 10). I think a better argument against Leinart is he has sooo much more talent around him than other QB in the nation. It is not fair.

For your RB list, if you not just going by stats, you have to put Jackson from Oregon St. in the top 3.

Nice coaching list. Myer was a very good honorable mention choice. My top 5 head coaches are.....
#1 Carroll
#2 Saban
#3 Tressel
#4 Stoops
#5 Ferentz (Iowa coach)

***Most up and coming head coach, TEDFORD without question. This guy will be a top 5 head coach of college football within the next 2 years.

I also think you were little too hard on Mack Brown. (i know you were being sarcastic). I would rate Brown a top 15 head coach. (coaching+recruiting+state of program all factored in)

Once again, nice list and interesting thread. Should be interesting to hear more replies and opinions. :thumb:

 

[scott]

you are right, i did forget udeze, didnt see him play much, but he should of been on the list

 

[The Big Tease]

Wow...imagine that, Scott correcting someones opinion telling them that the guys from USC are the best.......LOL

Here is my list.

QB: Craig Krenzel

RB: Lydell Ross

WR: Michael Jenkins

Coach: Jim Tressel

And we had the best defense in America.

LMFAO!

 

[jpblack34]

Gosh TBT...don't be so biased....your schools not the best!