Fantasy football question, any thoughts will help

[Steve's plays]

1st round of playoffs and i have vick going against the #1 defense in football. my alternative is to go with brad johnson who has played great at home this year. should i stick with vick or go with johnson at home. any replies will help, thank you.
:shrug:

 

[Fabulous]

Thats a tough call. I hate Brad Johnson and think he sucks but TB's defense is a real bit@# and they cause a lot of turnovers and put a great deal of pressure on QB's. Does your league penalize QB's for sacks, int's, and fumbles? If so how much. How many points do you get for QB yards rushing/passing and TD's. All these would have to be considered before I could provide a reasonable answer to your delima.

 

[jpblack34]

I am in the exact dilemma with the exact two quarterbacks. So, I can tell you what I have decided and maybe it will help you. Asking locals around here, just trying to get an idea, more people have leaned towards Vick. Coach Reeves said that Vick was such a valuable player because defenses have to adjust there schemes and never get to play to there full potential. So, i'm sticking with Vick hoping even if they stop him rushing, that he and Finneran will get into a flow. Hope this helps.

 

[kbyoda]

I would start Vick..............no question about it!!!

My dilemma and anyone of you can maybe help me since I am in a similar QB dilemma. McNabb was my QB and I have 3 Qb's who all basically suck...but need some insight. Do I start:

Drew Brees
Jon Kitna
Kerry Collins

My lean is to Kitna since he is going against Car. I have started Brees last 2 weeks and he didnt get me 1 stinkin TD. Conway has been out and is questinable this week.

Anybody have any thoughts?

 

[motley plays]

Go with Vick, he like a QB/RB in one. Tough defense, but with speed it can be beat.


motley

 

[Grama]

I'm riding Vick to the playoffs and to the championship. If anybody can do damage against Tampa, Vick can. Don't fix what isn't broken.