Help choosing a dog?

layinwood

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 29, 2001
4,771
40
0
Dallas, TX
Ok here's my situation. I love dogs but I've only had one in my life and it was a boxer. I loved it and would love to have another one.

I'm married and we have a 4.5 and 3 year old. We think it's finally time to get a dog because I want one and my 3 yr old little boy LOVES dogs. My wife wants a small dog but I can't do it, I want something on the medium to big side.

What are your suggestions?


PS if my wife would say yes to a boxer then it wouldn't even be a question but she says no to the boxer so I have to look around.
 

kellyindallas

Registered User
Forum Member
Apr 28, 2006
1,552
32
0
Maybe a beagle isn't manly enough or big enough for you, but they are wonderful around children.
 

Chadman

Realist
Forum Member
Apr 2, 2000
7,501
42
48
SW Missouri
If you could possibly lean to the bigger side, I can't recommend a Golden Retriever enough. Both myself and my best friend locally have them, and have children that interact with them all the time. There is (IMO) no more loyal breed, and they will happily take a pounding from aggressive smaller kids without getting aggressive back. My stepson was a little scared of bigger dogs, and having the Golden puppy grow up with him made all the difference.

Have never heard a bad thing about Goldens, and when ours passes on, we will either have one or two more immediately after.

Other friends of ours have a Beagle, and he is really good around kids, too. Good luck.
 

The Boys

Registered
Forum Member
Oct 17, 2001
15,365
217
0
78
Royal Oak, Michigan, a Detroit Suburb
I know I'll probably take some ribbing for this, but I had a Standard Poodle for 14 years and this is the smartest dog I have ever been around. On top of that it's very protective, has a strong bark, doesn't shed and is hypo allergenic. They were breed for bird hunting so their great swimmers. Weighed in at about 90 lbs, so their not small.

suckling.jpg
 

Franky Wright

Registered User
Forum Member
May 28, 2002
3,363
16
0
57
Heaven, oh!!, this isn't it?!
I know I'll probably take some ribbing for this, but I had a Standard Poodle for 14 years and this is the smartest dog I have ever been around. On top of that it's very protective, has a strong bark, doesn't shed and is hypo allergenic. They were breed for bird hunting so their great swimmers. Weighed in at about 90 lbs, so their not small.

suckling.jpg

Boyz,
Did you or can you hunt with that breed?

Franky
 

Happy Hippo

Registered
Forum Member
Mar 2, 2006
4,794
120
0
Australian Shepherd - they are medium sized...40-50 lbs., extremely smart, extraordinarily beautiful (at least I think so), great guardians, and will do anything you ask of them. They love to please. My dog is half aussie and I absolutely adore her personality...very loving. How could you refuse their smiles?

imageD2E.JPG


australian_shepherd_pups_01.jpg
 

Agent 0659

:mj07:
Forum Member
Dec 21, 2003
17,712
243
0
50
Gym rat
Goldens are awesome, Labs, can't go wrong there either.

I have a Yellow Lab Australian Shepard mix (what a dog!) and a Black Lab German Shepard mix. They are both super dogs. Why did she say no to the Boxer?
 

Happy Hippo

Registered
Forum Member
Mar 2, 2006
4,794
120
0
I would also add that you should definitely get one from the humane society/pound whatever is in your area - so many great dogs from there and it is a shame if any of them are put down... mutts from the pound can really be the best dogs in the world! Plus they are cheaper than getting one from a breeder, and you can usually find what you are looking for with a little patience...good luck!
 

AR182

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 9, 2000
18,654
87
0
Scottsdale,AZ
I would also add that you should definitely get one from the humane society/pound whatever is in your area - so many great dogs from there and it is a shame if any of them are put down... mutts from the pound can really be the best dogs in the world! Plus they are cheaper than getting one from a breeder, and you can usually find what you are looking for with a little patience...good luck!

i have a friend who is very involved in the dog world & suggested that we get a 2 year old female...& we did.

i agree with hh...we picked up a cockapoo (sp?)/poodle (17-20 lbs) mix at the humane society about 10 years ago...& have found her to be very friendly to all people & especially kids.

good luck with the choice.
 

The Boys

Registered
Forum Member
Oct 17, 2001
15,365
217
0
78
Royal Oak, Michigan, a Detroit Suburb
Boyz,
Did you or can you hunt with that breed?

Franky

I didn't hunt with my dog Franky, but here's an article that explains how they were breed and used.


The true origin of the Poodle is unknown but it was popular in portrait paintings over 400 years ago. Many believe that he was first developed in Germany where he was called the Pudel. He may have come to France by way of German soldiers during early Renaissance times. In France, he is still called Chien Canard or duck dog because his original purpose was to retrieve fowl that hunters had downed in water. Over time three varieties, Standard, Miniature and Toy, were created. The only difference between each variety is the size. All other key characteristics are the same.

The Poodle is an extremely intelligent breed. He is lively, good-natured, friendly and extremely loyal. Although he began as a hunting dog, he has become popular as a circus performer and as a companion. Because the Poodle does not shed his coat, he is an ideal dog for people with allergies.

The head of the Poodle is long, narrow and straight with a slight but definite stop (drop-off between skull and muzzle between the eyes). The teeth come together in a scissors bite. The eyes are dark, almond-shaped and set wide apart. The ears are long, wide and hang close to the face with abundant feathering. The back is short. The legs are straight and muscular. The feet are small, compact and oval shaped with arched toes. The gait is light and springy with the legs moving parallel to one another and the head carried high. The tail is docked and carried erect. The coat is dense and harsh. Although the coat is not shed, it does grow continuously so needs regular clipping and brushing. The coat is profuse with firm texture and curly but will cord when not combed. The coat may be any solid color including black, white, caf? au lait, apricot, brown, silver, gray or blue. Paricolors do exist but are discouraged by most registries. The coat may be cut in various different styles. The original purpose of trimming the coat was to aid the dog in the water since its profuse coat would become cumbersome and heavy otherwise. Size of each variety is: Standard, height over fifteen inches and weight between 45 and 70 pounds; Miniature, height ten to fifteen inches (USA) eleven to fifteen inches (Great Britain), weight proportional; Toy, height less than ten or eleven inches; weight proportional.
 

Padre

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 11, 2000
1,183
26
0
San Diego CA
I know I'll probably take some ribbing for this, but I had a Standard Poodle for 14 years and this is the smartest dog I have ever been around. On top of that it's very protective, has a strong bark, doesn't shed and is hypo allergenic. They were breed for bird hunting so their great swimmers. Weighed in at about 90 lbs, so their not small.

suckling.jpg



If you look closely, the last dog is saying,"Damn, I got the ass end of this detail."

Now I know how that expression came about.
 

IntenseOperator

DeweyOxburger
Forum Member
Sep 16, 2003
17,897
63
0
Chicago
The bigger the dog

the bigger the piles

Ask wifey how she is with a shovel and bag:)

BTW

small dogs are only good for burritos

German shorthaired pointer is a great dog for kids.
 
Last edited:

crazycourt

Registered User
Forum Member
Apr 4, 2007
16
0
0
I really like beagles and labs. They are always good with kids but they tend to have a lot of medical issues. How about a mut?
 

dunclock

Registered User
Forum Member
Dec 22, 2001
11,899
125
63
64
Nashville, TN
I have to recommend my dog, Mini Schnauzer, 18-24 lb range, awesome personality, scary smart, do not shed a hair, cannot give/receive enough affection.

My fellow was a Katrina survivor and I adopted him from the schnauzer rescue organization for $80. He had all of his shots, been fixed, house broken and could not be a better pet!

Good luck in your search and it is good to adopt!
 

Kramer

Registered User
Forum Member
May 10, 2006
3,621
23
38
you can't go wrong with a Golden, I have a female
named Angel, dealing with human beings all day in
SoCal, she is an absolute must when I come thru
the door in the evening. Makes me forget about
all the assholes out their. Can't ask for a more
affectionent critter for kids. House broke in weeks,
not months. The only downside to goldens and
I've had 2, the first year and a half they like to dig
craters in the yard, and chew on valuables. Every
dog has its negatives.
 

jr11

08-18-05
Forum Member
Jul 19, 2002
5,830
29
0
113
HELL
I have 2 pure bred German Shepherds, and they are the best imo. Very loyal and trainable. Both females, one 100 lbs and the other 80 lbs. I didn't read the whole thing through, but whatever you decide get a puppy and let it grow with your kids.

jr11
 

Glenn Quagmire

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 15, 2005
7,067
0
0
It's kind of ironic but before I even opened the thread the first thing that popped into my head was a boxer. Just perfect dogs if you ask me. If boxers are a no-go though, I can't recommend border collies highly enough. Very loving dogs, GREAT with kids and other animals, and just brilliant dogs. I've read that they are supposedly the smartest breed there is. Although as was mentioned before poodles are incredibly smart too. The only word of caution, and you may already know this, is that border collies are VERY active dogs. They need to be exercised and will play fetch with you until they are literally ready to pass out from exhaustion. I suppose in that respect if you want more of a lounging around, laid-back housedog, the Border Collie might not be the way to go.

Good luck with whatever you get. Dogs make the world go round as far as I'm concerned.
 

kickserv

Wrong Forum Mod
Forum Member
May 26, 2002
89,842
1,362
113
50
Canada
Can't go wrong black lab or golden lab :SIB


But whatever you decide....get the dog at the Humane Society.....horrible having to put down so many dogs because nobody wants them:nono:
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top