It's OK if Marshall loses this week. It's OK if it doesn't win what has to be considered the biggest game in school history. Most of all, it's all right if its magnificent quarterback, Byron Leftwich, fails.
Try telling that to the 53,000 residents of Huntington, W.Va.
Marshall has played football for 102 years but has never had a bigger game than the one it will play Thursday night at Virginia Tech. In the second week of September, it's for the all the marbles. Credibility, rankings, prestige, Heisman.
That's where Leftwich comes in.
Right now, any right-thinking American should agree that Leftwich is the current front-runner to win the ultimate trophy. The Grossman-Dorsey Heisman Show on Saturday night pretty much was a flop. The two (former) front-runners combined to throw five interceptions.
"We've got the guy," said Virginia Tech coach Frank Beamer, "that most people think is the best quarterback in the country."
"In a just world," said Kellen Winslow, whose son is Ken Dorsey's tight end, "the Heisman Trophy goes to the best player in the country. Byron Leftwich is that player."
But peering out from the second week of September, history would indicate Leftwich won't win it.
All the old roadblocks have been posted. In the past 40 years, only one player from a non-BCS school has won the award (Ty Detmer in 1990). Even then, BYU had an advantage given its quarterback heritage. For Leftwich, there has been and will be the MAC stigma. All the yards (8,104 of them so far) tend not to mean as much to college football elitists because of the competition.
You can hear them now: "Yeah but a lot of those yards were against Toledo, Kent and Ohio."
Says Marshall coach Bob Pruett: "They said that about Randy Moss. He's the best receiver in the National Football League. Byron's the best quarterback in college football right now."
That's why years from now, Thursday night might be looked back upon as Leftwich's coming out. Not that he hasn't been publicized enough, with his own bobblehead, website and postcards. But he still plays in the Mid-American Conference, the league the Central Florida president called the "Midwest Conference."
He still plays in Huntington, W.Va., which you first have to want to get to before trying to. He was passed up by the major powers coming out of Washington, D.C., reportedly getting only three scholarship offers.
"We felt like we were getting a steal when we recruited him," Pruett said.
Thursday is not only his night, it's a paid commercial for the mid-majors. The nation is Leftwich's stage in a stand-alone game on national television.
It's OK if he loses, but it's better, of course, if he doesn't. Look what winning did for Kelly Clarkson. Look what it could do for Leftwich. The spectacular GMAC Bowl victory over East Carolina did more for Leftwich's visibility than anything he did in four previous seasons.
Try amazing your friends with this stat: Add in Leftwich's 566 yards in the bowl game -- which the NCAA is doing this year -- and he finishes No. 1 in total offense last season, not Grossman. Leftwich is what every coach is looking for these days -- a big guy with a strong arm who can run. Grossman and Dorsey are not noted scramblers.
But this is not about downgrading one guy to upgrade the other. It's a simple realization that Thursday is huge. Florida-Miami Jr. If it can sort out the quarterback question, Virginia Tech is showing signs that it is as good as 1999. But the reason that team is remembered is Michael Vick.
The reason folks will remember this game is Leftwich.
Fans, and voters, love offense. Marshall has had plenty of it under Pruett, sending Chad Pennington and Moss to New York for the Heisman ceremony. Moss finished fourth in 1997. Pennington was fifth in 1999.
But everyone knew they were just there as curious, getting consolation prizes for having fine seasons at Marshall. As a collegian, Leftwich is better than both. Moss overcame a troubled past to finally succeed with the Herd in college. Pennington, despite being an up-and-comer with the Jets, didn't have the arm, height or mobility of Leftwich. The biggest roadblock could also be his throne on Thursday night. So far in his brilliant career, Leftwich has never beaten a Big Six school, schools in the Bowl Championship Series conferences that control college football. In essence, the football gods won't let him. Marshall has played only five BCS schools while Leftwich has been there. He has played in only three of those games. All of them have been on the road.
"You have to go to Nebraska three or four times before they come to play you," said Pruett, who wasn't able to schedule a 12th game because schools were averse to coming to Huntington.
It's a vicious cycle. Marshall is one of those schools that is too dangerous for a Big Six school to schedule, which means their schedule is too weak to get into a BCS bowl. Even Virginia Tech won't be getting much BCS computer juice from taking the game.
It's gridiron collusion.
It is a cycle that will only accelerate in the future as the BCS powers further try to build a wall between themselves and the mid-majors. It's almost like Augusta National. Prospective members don't apply. One day a letter comes in the mail, and you're asked to join.
That isn't going to happen anytime soon for Marshall. It might have its sights set on Conference USA, which has its sights set on BCS inclusion by 2006, but don't hold your breath. Marshall must decide within a couple of weeks to join C-USA as early as next season. There already is a huge stumbling block, which is what to do with basketball and the minor sports.
That problem is still being pondered by school officials.
Besides, a short history of the universe tells you that the BCS doesn't want any more members in its exclusive club. The proposed minimum I-A membership standards due to go in effect in 2004 are a good indicator. If anything, less, not more, is the future of the BCS.
But for Leftwich, it's OK to fail Thursday. That's because Leftwich, win or lose, will still be the best player in the country. He is more athletic and has a better arm than either Grossman or Dorsey.
Both guys are light years closer to winning a national championship than Leftwich, but it seems that neither will make an NFL impact like Leftwich will. Lord Byron is 6-feet-6, mobile, coachable, has a rocket arm and is just waiting for this year's worst NFL team (Arizona? Cincinnati? Dallas?) to snatch him up in April. That's because right now Leftwich is the No. 1 pick in the NFL Draft.
Quick, name an NFL quarterback you'd pay to go see besides Vick, Peyton Manning and Kurt Warner. Kerry Collins? Jeff Garcia? Brian Griese? Sorry, Troy Aikman is in the booth now, and don't even try to say Tom Brady with a straight face.
Leftwich is the next member of that exclusive club.
Gil Brandt was being interviewed on various subjects before the season. Unprovoked, the NFL personnel guru blurted, "You know who is really good? Byron Leftwich."
CBS analyst Todd Blackledge was being asked about Grossman and Dorsey.
"Marshall in that system has been very, very successful," Blackledge said. "The MAC is good football. They've been the dominant team in that league. Leftwich is an awful good quarterback, too."
They can't get him out of their minds. But to see him, you have to make an effort, find Marshall's games in a sports bar. Try doing that, though, in any testosterone-filled wings-and-beer establishment. Who wants to watch Marshall?
The needle on the prejudice meter is buried in the red on all fronts. The funky green uniforms, the 38,000-seat stadium, the conference.
"I didn't ask for this situation," Leftwich said. "I didn't turn it down either."
A load of credit goes to Pruett, a former Florida assistant who has turned down offers to go elsewhere to be the king of Huntington. He worked with Leftwich and was rewarded with the best, until further notice, offense in the country.
The hard work was rewarded when Leftwich became eligible for the NFL Draft after last season.
"I never once thought about leaving," Leftwich said. "I told my teammates, 'No matter what happens, I'm not going nowhere.' Those guys knew I wouldn't go nowhere. I couldn't leave my family like this."
Most likely nothing will change after Thursday night. Despite Leftwich, Virginia Tech should win. The same prejudices will still be there. The elitists will turn up their noses. They'll say, "I told you so."
Unless Marshall wins. That would be more than OK with the residents of Huntington and their Lord Byron.