mcfadden or murray?

[snoozer]

I am in a 12 team league with 2 keepers. I have Murray, McFadden and Rice.

I was offered the first pick in the sixth round for murray or the 4th pick in the 4th round for McFadden... which would you take?

 

[IX_Bender]

Hmm

so you HAVE to get rid of one, b/c you cant keep em all , right?


Id ditch Murray as the drop of 20 spots to keep McFadden is well worth it, plus theres plenty of talent left in the 6th to grab a body.

 

[snoozer]

right, I am keeping rice for sure, so I can keep one other player.

He just bumped up the offer for Mcfadden to a 3rd.

 

[fatdaddycool]

right, I am keeping rice for sure, so I can keep one other player.

He just bumped up the offer for Mcfadden to a 3rd.

tell him to make it a second or you will give him Murray for the third rounder. If you have to drop one I would make the trade for the third round pick ultimately but I would try to keep Fad.

 

[HUDSON]

Run DMC hands down!!! He has a lot to prove this year and Oakland is giving him the keys to prove that! No Bush was a huge statement! Everyone and their mother is saying Fad will NOT play full season....he proves them wrong just like Stafford did last year and put up HUGE numbers!!! Thank me later! I would even take Fad over McCoy at the #3 RB behind Foster and Rice!

 

[Old School]

and 2 Oak receivers are down so Mac in the lone attack..

man o man do the Raiders like really really suck for the last 12 years.

sorry ass franchise