Two Comments:
POINT 1: "props are a coin flip" -- This may be true, in fact I HOPE it's true. What give me value on the prop is getting back +110 on the prop. Note that every prop I make I am getting back better than EVEN money. If you want to give me +110 on a coin flip, that's a helluva bargain. As far as INDY scoring first prop, it obviously did not work out. But assuming that's a coin flip, why would you not go for the 100/110 payoff ? It's all about value, right?
NOTE: Miami does tend to start off slowly, as another post mentioned. That was also a factor.
POINT 2: About INDY's lack of enthusiasm before the game. I'm not sure it's just a feeling or something tangible. But as the announcers are talking before the game and images are being flashed from both sidelines, you saw the Dolphins jumping up and down in a huddle and appeared ready to go (like it was a college game). You saw Wannstedt barking at the team, and lots of energy. They showed the Indy sideline and we saw a stonefaced Jim Mora, Peyton Manning looking like a dear in the headlights (a look on his face like -- "here we go again"), and none of the players were the least bit encouraging to one another. Admittedly, these were brief images and only conveyed a general impression. I have no idea what was actualy being said on the field or the mood of the team. But, as we saw -- the Colts were flat from the kickoff. There's no handicapping angle here (not like seeing horses in the paddock before the race), just an initial read into the team(s).
One counterpoint is -- some teams can be TOO HIGH emotionally. When you see the underdog bouncing up and down like they are back in college that energy can work against a team (it happens all the time in college).
Also, have you ever noticed that you can see how your bet will do after just 1 or 2 plays? You see one team fired up and slapping each other after a tackle, while the other team just gets up and walks towards the huddle. I really do belive emotions (when it's combined with displine) is perhaps the most powerful component in football.
-- Nolan Dalla