Posted on Thu, Sep. 02, 2004
Preseason has a place
Exhibition wins often linked to success in postseason
STAN OLSON
Staff Writer
PITTSBURGH - They're just exhibitions, right? They let NFL veterans shake off the rust, rookies strut their stuff and coaches determine those final few spots on the roster. Then the regular season starts, every team is 0-0 again and the preseason games are forgotten.
Which means that winning in the preseason shouldn't matter. Many in the NFL, though, say it matters a lot.
If it does, that bodes well for the Carolina Panthers, who will try to wrap up their second straight undefeated preseason tonight at 6:30 against Pittsburgh at Heinz Field.
The game won't overwhelm anyone; both teams plan to use their starters sparingly after giving them considerable work last week. But both squads still prefer winning this last warmup contest to the alternative.
Consider this: The Panthers, who are chasing their ninth straight preseason victory, went 4-0 last year and reached the Super Bowl. New England went 4-0 last year and won the Super Bowl.
Keep in mind that you would expect the best teams to win in the preseason because of their talent, just as they do in the regular season. And the 38 Super Bowl winners have for the most part been dominant in the preseason.
Thirty (78.9 percent) had an exhibition winning percentage of .500 or higher. Seven went undefeated. Overall, the Super Bowl champions combined for a 115-65-2 preseason record.
"It is a lot more fun to win," Panthers coach John Fox said. "The mindset is different; you get used to it. I am not saying anybody will ever remember what the (preseason) record was, but I think it is important to get your team ready to win.
"We do everything we can to win. We are not going to put our first group in to win a game; we are not going to do anything dumb.
"But winning these games breeds the idea of winning."
Carolina offensive coordinator Dan Henning has worked with many of the game's greatest coaches.
"Bill Parcells always wanted to win, Don Shula always wanted to win," Henning said. "Because they felt like winning bred on itself. That didn't mean they didn't address other issues, they just made winning a priority also. So they decided whoever was in the blankety-blank game was going to win. Don was adamant about it, and Bill thought it was important."
Not everyone is enamored of preseason wins. Henning said neither Joe Gibbs nor Marv Levy placed a high priority on beating exhibition opponents.
Gibbs' 1982 Washington team was the only Super Bowl winner to go winless in the preseason.
"Different people look at it differently," Henning said.
But after watching both approaches first-hand, Henning prefers winning.
Still, work has to be done, sometimes to the detriment of the final score.
"The difference in preseason is that you have other issues to address during the course of the game, and sometimes they get in the way of what you would actually do to win or lose," Henning said.
Henning remembered Fox's first exhibition as a head coach, following a 1-15 season. The Panthers were leading Washington, but lost the lead while playing substitutes.
"There was a lot of weeping and gnashing of teeth around, but there wasn't with John," Henning said. "He knew exactly what he wanted to get done. We started out that season 3-0, and the reason was because of the issues that we addressed, being a new staff and needing to see everybody and put things together."
Henning said you approach exhibitions with "a whole different set of encyclopedias," but added, "I think it's important to win, to find a way to win no matter what issues you're addressing."
Defensive end Mike Rucker understands that sometimes winning must take a backseat to preparing the team. But he also believes a part of that preparation is learning how to win.
"It is the preseason, so you've got a lot of young guys. You've got a lot of people trying to jell and you're trying to see a lot of things," he said. "On the other hand, winning is good because now you start to build some of these little things that help you on down the road. You learn how to deal with wins and how to deal with success."
This is really the way it works in the NFL's preseason: Each week's winners smile and talk about building momentum for the real thing. Each week's losers grumble and say it was only an exhibition.
Maybe, though, it was a little bit more than that.
Exhibiting Winning Tendencies
The preseason records of the past 10 Super Bowl champions:
Year Team W-L
2003 New England 4-0
2002 Tampa Bay 3-1
2001 New England 3-1
2000 Baltimore 4-0
1999 St. Louis 2-2
1998 Denver 3-1
1997 Denver 3-2
1996 Green Bay 3-1
1995 Dallas 2-3
1994 San Francisco 3-1
Total 30-12 .714