Blue Jay,
Here are a few additional thoughts to go along with the great comments posted above. As important as it is in choosing the right service, I think it is also equally, yes equally important in having multiple outs. Line variation whether it be with a few locals or with a few different offshores or better yet both, is unbelievably important. Just look at last night. Carolina getting 7 lands on the number. Giants -3 lands on the number. Tennessee -2 lands on the number 2. You have good numbers or multiple outs you win all three. I had Tennessee at 1- locally, Carolina +7- locally and bought the Giants to 2- offshore. Doesn't matter what any service said about those 3 games if you had good numbers, or play smart and buy the 1/2 you win. Always buy off the number 3 in the NFL. You will be surprised at how many times the oddsmakers are right on. Never buy in College.
In addition to multiple books and buying at the right time is the importance of money management. If you have the money to play with, thats fine. But if you find yourself crying over losses or getting over emotional, either cut back on your wagers or get out. I was on a sports radio show one time here in Chicago with a gentlemen named Tommy Jackson, (I believe) and he asked me about a Monday Night Football game in which Jacksonville was going to kick a Field Goal (they already had covered) and it got not only blocked but returned for a TD. Hence my 3 unit play lost. He asked me how I handle that type of beat. Did I jump up and down, scream, swear or throw something? "No." I replied, "I just shook my head and went to bed." Bet wagers you are more than comfortable with and if you have a bad beat you take it easier.
SixFive had some very good comments about finding someone to fade. Makes complete sense but it also takes a lot of homework to find out who is good and who is bad. I found it very interesting that ferdville mentioned one of the few services I would recommend in Ken Angland. Ken caught my eye in last years UHC contest where he finished second. I finished 13th. He got beat out by the Crazy Cajun (Brian Carpenter) on the last day of the season. Both of these 2 guys are pretty tough cappers. But Ken especially since he finished 1st in the UHC in Pro Football, 2nd like I said in Baseball and in the top 10 in College Football also. He also finished 1st the year before in the NBA which is some pretty remarkable stats out of over 100 services. This past NBA season he did not fair so well. ferdville also stated that Ken "showed a healthy profit for about 3 consecutive years." Thats a decent enough review. Ken is also a great guy.
jcjrbowl had some great observations in "We here at mad jacks are just as good or bad as most pay services." I absolutely agree 100%. I am not a service and in the last year I finished 13th in the UHC Baseball, 10th in Pro Football and am currently in the top 5 at the NSM in overall and this years Baseball. I say this not to brag but to just show proof that you can get free info that is just as good as what you would be paying probably $2000 -$3000 for. Save that money, thats a decent starting bankroll.
I also agree with djv that Nolan will have a little different year than last. I looked forward to competing against him in last years UHC and he did terrible. That happens. I remember the year before he was fantastic and look for him to go back to his winning ways this year. Don't forget about MadJack. I still say that if I was to give anyone my money to play with it would be Jack. I have watched him for a few years now and I think he is a brilliant player. Doesn't play favs in Bases and is very smart in both College and Pro Football. Just ignore his Ravens bets.
DOGS THAT BARK is offering just what this is all about. Offering help and honest stats to back them up. ferdville also asked that "maybe those in the know can tell us which of the monitoring services are legit." I am monitored by several and all I can comment on is what I have participated in and that is the UHC, NSM and here at Bestbettor. I am ranked in the top 10 in all 3 and I think all 3 are honest and run well. You know one form of monitoring that can very well be kept track of and that is the sports forum itself. Un-edited posts do not lie. Just takes a bit of homework.
DogFace looking forward to you competing in the UHC (which allows you to use your 1-5 units) and the NSM which allows you only 1 unit per play but unlimited plays. Both are great contests but each is different in its own right.
All in all Blue Jay I recommend you use your service fee for a nice starting bankroll of about $2500. Allows you to start out at $25 per unit and on 1-3 units thats 1-3% of your bankroll. No pressure to win right away as you would have just lost that $2500 right off the bat. Watch Nolan, especially watch Jack and watch the other good players that this forum has to offer. Then decide who to follow, who to fade, and establish that feel for yourself of what to do when. Good Luck. By the way most services actually put up their picks on the free picks pages at the above mentioned monitoring sites.