Here are my rankings for pitchers based on a handful of stats I find important. I use them to get a gauge on a pitcher's overall performance and use that number and recent form when handicapping. The number will mean nothing to you, it is just a number I assign to each player based on numerous stats. Higher number = better overall pitcher.
I'll also list my bullpen rankings based on the same formula.
I've found them to be a key in my line projections and handicapping.
The individuals are listed in 3 categories based on innings pitched. Stats through Tuesday's games, May 26.
Bullpen
1 Boston 40.7
2 Milwaukee 40.4
3 Oakland 39.8
4 St. Louis 39.6
5 Toronto 39.1
6 NY Mets 39
7 LA Dodgers 38.6
8 Philadelphia 38.3
9 Kansas City 38.2
10 Atlanta 38.1
11 Florida 38
12 Cincinnati 38
13 San Diego 37.7
14 Chicago Sox 37.1
15 San Francisco 37
16 Seattle 36.3
17 Tampa Bay 36.1
18 Pittsburgh 35.8
19 Chicago Cubs 35.8
20 Detroit 35.7
21 Minnesota 34.7
22 Arizona 34.7
23 Baltimore 34.6
24 Houston 34.3
25 Cleveland 34.2
26 NY Yankees 33.8
27 Colorado 33.8
28 LA Angels 33.1
29 Texas 32.9
30 Washington 31.5
American League
Individual Pitcher Rating
Category 1
IP > Team Games
Rank Rating Player IP
1 51.1 Zack Greinke 75
2 47.5 Justin Verlander 63.1
3 44 Roy Halladay 75
4 43.9 Erik Bedard 47.2
5 42 Edwin Jackson 66.1
6 41.5 Jered Weaver 60.2
7 41.2 Matt Garza 66.2
8 41.1 Felix Hernandez 64.2
9 40.7 CC Sabathia 71
10 39.5 Mark Buehrle 59
11 39.5 Jarrod Washburn 57.1
12 39 Cliff Lee 68
13 38.5 Scott Richmond 52
14 38.4 Koji Uehara 50.2
15 37.6 John Danks 49
16 37.4 Brian Tallet 54.1
17 36.9 Rick Porcello 45.2
18 36.9 Gil Meche 55.1
19 36.7 Joe Saunders 66.1
20 36.7 James Shields 67
21 36.5 Kevin Millwood 72
22 36.4 Kyle Davies 52.2
23 36.4 Josh Beckett 55.2
24 36.3 Tim Wakefield 58.2
25 36.2 Nick Blackburn 63.1
26 35.9 Dallas Braden 61
27 35.7 Carl Pavano 55.2
28 35.5 Kevin Slowey 55.1
29 35 A.J. Burnett 58
30 34.7 Bartolo Colon 45
31 34.1 Vicente Padilla 49.2
32 34.1 Brandon McCarthy 54
33 34 Andy Pettitte 58.2
34 33.9 Jon Lester 59.1
35 33.8 Glen Perkins 47
36 32.8 Francisco Liriano 54.2
37 32.6 Scott Baker 47
38 32.6 Jeremy Guthrie 60.2
39 32 Gavin Floyd 52.1
40 31.9 Brett Anderson 43.1
41 31.7 Armando Galarraga 47
42 31.2 Matt Harrison 54.2
43 30.9 Brad Penny 48.1
44 30.3 Trevor Cahill 48.2
45 30.3 Fausto Carmona 54.2
Category 2
IP < Team Games &
> Team Games/ 3
1 51.9 Frank Francisco 16.2
2 49 Andrew Bailey 29.2
3 48.5 Scott Downs 20.1
4 47.6 David Aardsma 21.2
5 47.4 Michael Wuertz 23
6 46.7 Ramon Ramirez 24.1
7 46.7 Matt Thornton 18.1
8 46 Octavio Dotel 15.1
9 46 Hideki Okajima 20
10 45.3 Robinson Tejeda 17
11 44.8 Manny Delcarmen 21
12 44.5 J.P. Howell 22
13 44.2 Joe Nathan 17.1
14 43.8 Jason Frasor 16.2
15 43.2 Ryan Perry 19.1
16 43.2 Mariano Rivera 19.2
17 42.9 Scott Linebrink 17
18 42.5 Darren Oliver 21.2
19 42 Alfredo Aceves 16.2
20 41.9 Jonathan Papelbon 21
21 41.7 George Sherrill 19.2
22 41.7 Fernando Rodney 18
23 41.4 Jason Vargas 21
24 41.3 Kyle Farnsworth 16
25 41.3 Danys Baez 24.2
26 40.9 Matt Guerrier 23.1
27 40.7 Brian Fuentes 16.2
28 40.6 Takashi Saito 17
29 40.5 Juan Cruz 20
30 40.3 Lance Cormier 34
31 40.1 Jesse Carlson 25.2
32 40 Jose Arredondo 21
33 39.7 Rafael Betancourt 25.2
34 39.5 Josh Outman 40.1
35 39.1 D.J. Carrasco 31.2
36 39 Santiago Casilla 18.1
37 39 Brian Bannister 42
38 38.8 Bobby Jenks 16
39 38.6 Brandon League 20.2
40 38 Justin Masterson 44.1
41 37.4 Joba Chamberlain 45.1
42 37.4 Jim Johnson 23.1
43 37.3 Sean White 22.1
44 37.2 Scott Feldman 42.1
45 36.7 Miguel Batista 24
46 36.6 Jamey Wright 23.1
47 36.2 Ricky Romero 26.1
48 36.1 Clayton Richard 33
49 36 Jason Bulger 17.2
50 36 Dontrelle Willis 17.2
51 35.6 Justin Speier 18.1
52 35.6 Jason Jennings 20.1
53 35.6 Aaron Laffey 34.1
54 35.3 Brad Ziegler 19.1
55 35.2 Matt Palmer 37.1
56 35.2 Dan Wheeler 16.2
57 35.2 C.J. Wilson 18.2
58 35.1 Robert Ray 24.1
59 35.1 Grant Balfour 20.1
60 34.8 Jose Veras 19.1
61 34.4 Brian Bass 30.1
62 34.1 Phil Coke 20.1
63 33.6 Mark Lowe 23.2
64 33.5 Derek Holland 18.2
65 33.3 Ron Mahay 16.2
66 33.1 R.A. Dickey 26.1
67 33 Russ Springer 17.1
68 32.9 Phil Hughes 29.2
69 32.6 Jensen Lewis 24.2
70 32.6 Brett Cecil 24.2
71 32.5 Lance Broadway 16
72 32.5 Kerry Wood 16
73 32.3 Garrett Olson 19.2
74 31.7 Luis Ayala 20.2
75 31.6 Jeff Niemann 47.2
76 31.1 Zach Miner 28.1
77 31 David Purcey 25.2
78 30.5 Joe Nelson 19
79 30.5 Dan Giese 22
80 30.2 Sidney Ponson 43
81 30.2 Shawn Camp 16.2
82 30.2 Scot Shields 17.2
83 30 Mark Hendrickson 34
84 29.9 Chris Jakubauskas 44.2
85 29.3 Shane Loux 38.1
86 29.3 Brad Bergesen 39.1
87 29.3 Anthony Reyes 38.1
88 29 Andy Sonnanstine 46.1
89 28.1 Jonathan Albaladejo 21
90 27.2 Edwar Ram?*rez 17.1
91 26.7 Brandon Lyon 21
92 26.3 Scott Kazmir 45.2
93 25.7 Horacio Ramirez 18.1
94 24.7 Jose Contreras 29.2
95 24.6 Adam Eaton 41
96 23.8 Carlos Silva 28.2
97 22.6 Dana Eveland 24.1
98 21.1 Kris Benson 18
Category 3
IP < Team Games/3
1 70 Romon Colon 1
2 68.2 John Bale 1.1
3 60 Michael Bowden 2
4 55.6 Brian Bruney 9
5 50 Luke French 3
6 50 Jeff Gray 0.1
7 48.2 Matt Herges 11.2
8 47.5 Darren O'Day 12
9 46.7 Craig Breslow 3
10 46.4 Kevin Cameron 14
11 46.2 David Robertson 5.2
12 45.1 Joakim Soria 8.2
13 45.1 Brian Wolfe 6.1
14 44.3 Anthony Swarzak 7
15 44 Edgar González 5
16 43.8 Shawn Kelley 11.2
17 42.9 José Mijares 14
18 41.7 Nick Adenhart 6
19 41.6 Joel Zumaya 13.1
20 41 Rich Hill 11.1
21 40.1 Bobby Seay 13.1
22 40 Rich Rundles 1
23 40 Randy Choate 2
24 40 Nick Swisher 1
25 40 Greg Aquino 5
26 39.2 Bill Murphy 11.1
27 38.1 Zach Jackson 4.2
28 36.7 Daniel Bard 6
29 36 Nate Robertson 12.1
30 35.8 John Lackey 12
31 35.1 Brian Shouse 14.1
32 33.9 Rich Thompson 3.1
33 33.6 Tony Sipp 6.1
34 33.3 Matt Albers 13.2
35 33.3 Bryan Bullington 6
36 33.3 Brian Duensing 3
37 33 Jamie Walker 10
38 32.2 Juan Rincón 10.1
39 32 Joe Smith 6.1
40 32 Jason Berken 5
41 31.6 Brandon Morrow 14.1
42 31.3 Sean Henn 3.2
43 30.9 Craig Breslow 14.1
44 30.8 Vinnie Chulk 12
45 30.3 Dustin Moseley 14.2
46 30 Casey Janssen 6
47 29.5 Dennis Sarfate 12.2
48 28.9 Hunter Jones 9
49 28.5 Jesse Crain 13
50 28 Gio González 8.2
51 27.5 Doug Waechter 4
52 27.4 Ryan Rowland-Smith 3.1
53 27.4 Mark Melancon 3.1
54 27.4 David Price 3.1
55 26.7 Jason Isringhausen 3
56 26.6 Troy Percival 11.1
57 26.6 Sean Gallagher 0
58 26.2 Warner Madrigal 4.2
59 25.6 Willie Eyre 4.1
60 25 Eddie Guardado 9.2
61 24.6 Ervin Santana 12.2
62 24.2 Luis Vizca?*no 3.1
63 24 Denny Stark 10
64 24 Bob McCrory 5
65 23.6 Jeremy Sowers 14
66 23.3 Jesse Litsch 9
67 23.2 Brett Tomko 4.1
68 22.8 Masa Kobayashi 9.2
69 22.3 B.J. Ryan 10.1
70 22.1 Rafael Rodr?*guez 14
71 21.8 Chris Ray 13.1
72 20.7 Dale Thayer 4.1
73 19.5 Roy Corcoran 8.2
74 18.3 Scott Lewis 4.1
75 18.3 Jimmy Gobble 4.1
76 18 Anthony Ortega 12.2
77 16.3 Eddie Bonine 8
78 16.1 Javier López 11.2
79 15.8 Daisuke Matsuzaka 11.1
80 15.2 Luke Hochevar 11.2
81 13.4 Jerry Blevins 0
82 12.3 Brian Burres 6.1
83 11.9 Clay Rapada 2.1
84 10.7 Alfredo Simon 6.1
85 8.8 Dámaso Marte 5.1
86 8.5 Mike MacDougal 4.1
87 7.8 Rafael Pérez 10.2
88 6.1 Philip Humber 4.1
89 -8.3 Daniel Davidson 1.2
90 -9.5 Kevin Jepsen 4.2
91 -10 Juan Morillo 0
92 -14.3 Josh Rupe 4.2
93 -20 Chien-Ming Wang 9
94 -40 Luis Mendoza 1
95 -40.9 Jack Egbert 2.2
96 -50 Jonathan Van Every 0.2
97 -125 Anthony Claggett 1.2
98 -140.9 Radhames Liz 1.1
99 -250 Fernando Rodr?*guez 0.2
National League
Individual Pitcher Rating
Category 1
IP > Team Games
Rank Rating Player IP
1 49 Johan Santana 60
2 47.2 Tim Lincecum 65.1
3 45.6 Dan Haren 63
4 45.4 Wandy Rodriguez 63
5 44.9 Chad Billingsley 67
6 44.8 Jake Peavy 67.1
7 44.7 Javier Vazquez 64
8 43.6 Josh Johnson 67.1
9 43 Johnny Cueto 60.2
10 42.9 Yovani Gallardo 59.2
11 41.6 Max Scherzer 50.2
12 41.2 Randy Wolf 62.2
13 41 Clayton Kershaw 50
14 40.9 Zach Duke 65
15 40.7 Jair Jurrjens 61
16 40.6 Adam Wainwright 65
17 39.9 Derek Lowe 62.2
18 39.7 Aaron Harang 64.1
19 39.5 Ted Lilly 57.1
20 39.4 Ubaldo Jiminez 53
21 39.4 Jorge De La Rosa 49.2
22 39.3 Chris Volstad 61
23 39 Matt Cain 60
24 39 Edinson Volquez 48.2
25 38.7 Kyle Lohse 54.1
26 37.8 Dave Bush 59.2
27 37.6 Kenshin Kawakami 45.2
28 37.1 Doug Davis 62
29 36.9 Joel Pinieiro 61.1
30 36.8 Barry Zito 56
31 36.7 Ryan Dempster 61.1
32 36.7 John Maine 51.2
33 36.6 Paul Maholm 61.1
34 36.5 Chris Young 56.2
35 35.5 Ross Ohlendorf 55.2
36 35.2 Roy Oswalt 62.1
37 34.7 Kevin Correia 49.1
38 34.6 Jason Marquis 60.2
39 34.1 Livan Hernandez 54.2
40 34 Brett Myers 58
41 33.7 Randy Johnson 46
42 33.6 Shairon Martis 53.2
43 33.2 Joe Blanton 51.1
44 33.1 Micah Owings 49
45 33 Ian Snell 53
46 32.7 Manny Parra 46.2
47 32.5 Mike Pelfrey 48
48 32.1 Mike Hampton 48
49 32.1 John Lannan 57
50 32 Braden Looper 50.1
51 32 Aaron Cook 56
52 31.7 Todd Wellemeyer 52
53 30.3 Jon Garland 53.2
54 29.6 Bronson Arroyo 56
55 28.9 Jeff Suppan 53.1
56 23.9 Jamie Moyer 47.1
Category 2
IP < Team Games &
> Team Games/ 3
1 57.8 Jonathan Broxton 23
2 53.9 Chris Carpenter 23
3 53.1 Heath Bell 19.1
4 52.1 Rafael Soriano 19.2
5 49.1 Kiko Calero 22.1
6 48.1 Mark DiFelice 21.2
7 48 Nick Masset 15.2
8 47.6 Francisco Rodriguez 21.2
9 47.5 Eric O'Flaherty 16.2
10 47.5 Arthur Rhodes 16
11 46.8 Ryan Madson 22.1
12 46.7 Francisco Cordero 21
13 46.5 Ryan Franklin 17.2
14 46.1 Randy Wells 18
15 45.7 Edward Mujica 23.1
16 45.5 Angel Guzman 20
17 45.3 Dan Meyer 19.2
18 44.3 Jesse Chavez 19.2
19 43.9 Pedro Feliciano 18.1
20 43.7 Mike Gonzalez 19
21 43.7 Carlos Villanueva 22.2
22 43.4 J.A. Happ 27.2
23 43 Luke Gregerson 27.1
24 43 Kyle McClellan 23
25 43 Chad Qualls 20
26 42.8 Huston Street 18.1
27 42.7 Juan Gutierrez 26.1
28 42.6 Ronald Belisario 27.2
29 42.4 Ramon Troncoso 30.1
30 42.2 Jason Motte 18
31 41.9 Tony Pena 22.1
32 41.5 Jeremy Affeldt 21.1
33 41.5 Carlos Marmol 20
34 41.4 Justin Miller 21
35 41.3 Jeff Fulchino 17.2
36 41.1 LaTroy Hawkins 19.2
37 40.5 Sean Burnett 21
38 40.5 Clay Condrey 24.2
39 40.1 Daniel Ray Herrera 17.2
40 40 Todd Coffey 22
41 40 Leo Nunez 23.1
42 40 Chris Sampson 28
43 39.6 Brian Wilson 21.1
44 39.6 Bobby Parnell 19.2
45 39.4 Rich Harden 43.2
46 38.9 David Weathers 16.2
47 38.6 Renyel Pinto 21.1
48 38.4 J.J. Putz 25.1
49 38.1 Brandon Medders 20.1
50 37.9 Carlos Zambrano 42.2
51 37.6 Jeff Bennett 21
52 37.6 Chad Durbin 25.1
53 37.4 Seth McClung 23.1
54 37.4 Jonathan Sanchez 43
55 37.2 Bob Howry 18
56 37.1 Tim Byrdak 17
57 37.1 Sean Marshall 41.1
58 36.9 Mitchell Boggs 22.1
59 36.8 Peter Moylan 15.2
60 36.7 Joel Hanrahan 21.1
61 36.7 Cole Hamels 42.1
62 36.4 Jeff Weaver 22.1
63 36.3 Julian Tavarez 19
64 36.3 Brian Stokes 18.2
65 36.2 Evan Meek 15.2
66 36.1 Jordan Zimmermann 41
67 35.7 Eric Stults 42
68 35.5 Chad Gaudin 33.1
69 35.1 Cla Meredith 16.1
70 35 Kip Wells 22
71 34.9 Andrew Miller 29.2
72 34.6 Burke Badenhop 20.1
73 34.5 Jason Grilli 16.1
74 34.3 John Grabow 21
75 34.2 Matt Lindstrom 19
76 34 Kevin Gregg 18.1
77 33.5 Josh Geer 40.1
78 33 Jorge Julio 17.1
79 32.7 Jason Hammel 37.1
80 32.3 Jack Taschner 19.2
81 32.2 Jo-Jo Reyes 27
82 32.1 Manuel Corpas 21.2
83 31.8 Aaron Heilman 19.2
84 31.7 Russ Ortiz 31.1
85 31.7 Joe Beimel 18
86 31.7 Jared Burton 20.2
87 31.7 Hayden Penn 20.2
88 31.3 Edwin Moreno 17.1
89 30.7 Jeff Karstens 43.1
90 30.1 Chan Ho Park 38.1
91 29.5 Anibal Sanchez 32.2
92 27.9 Sean Green 18.1
93 27.3 Felipe Paulino 30
94 26.9 James McDonald 18.2
95 26.4 Ricky Nolasco 43.2
96 26.1 Scott Olsen 41
97 25.8 Jon Rauch 18.2
98 25.8 Brian Moehler 26
99 25.3 Glendon Rusch 18.2
100 24.8 Daniel Cabrera 40
101 24.4 Yusmeiro Petit 24.2
102 24.4 Guillermo Mota 18
103 24.1 Brad Lidge 20.1
104 23 Geoff Geary 20
105 20.2 Buddy Carlyle 19.1
106 15 Mike Lincoln 16
Category 3
IP < Team Games/3
1 56.3 Randy Flores 3.2
2 55.9 Greg Burke 5.1
3 55 Clay Zavada 2
4 54.8 Sergio Escalona 2.1
5 53.8 Trevor Hoffman 13
6 53.1 Luis Vizca?*no 3.2
7 51.7 Brian Sanches 6
8 50 Manny Acosta 2
9 50 Josh Fogg 2
10 50 Joe Thatcher 1.2
11 46.4 Ross Detwiler 11
12 43.7 Ron Villone 11.1
13 43.5 José Ascanio 6.2
14 43.1 Chris Pérez 13.1
15 42.7 Matt Daley 8.2
16 42.3 Hiroki Kuroda 5.2
17 42 Tom Gorzelanny 5
18 41.6 Dennys Reyes 13.1
19 41 Trever Miller 11.1
20 40.3 Leo Rosales 7.2
21 40.1 Alberto Arias 9.1
22 40 Sean West 5
23 40 Josh Wilson 1
24 40 Franklin Morales 8
25 40 Cody Ross 1
26 40 Carlos Fisher 3
27 38.3 Brent Leach 6
28 37.5 José Valverde 8
29 37.5 Joel Peralta 3.2
30 37.3 Jonathon Niese 10.2
31 37.1 Merkin Valdez 13.2
32 36.8 Ken Takahashi 9.1
33 36.7 Eric Milton 9
34 36.7 Darren O'Day 3
35 36.6 Blaine Boyer 8.2
36 36.3 Mitch Stetter 13.1
37 36 Steven Shell 5
38 35.7 Ramon Ramirez 2.1
39 35.2 Brad Thompson 14.2
40 35.1 Scott Eyre 10.1
41 35 Nelson Figueroa 6
42 35 James Parr 14
43 35 Casey Fossum 4
44 34.3 Scott Schoeneweis 10.2
45 33.8 Craig Stammen 11.1
46 33.4 Luis Perdomo 15.1
47 33.3 Shawn Hill 12
48 32.2 Cory Wade 15.2
49 32 Craig Hansen 6.1
50 31.5 Jason Bergmann 8.1
51 30.8 Ryan Speier 5.2
52 30.4 Tim Redding 10.2
53 30.1 David Patton 14.1
54 30 Ross Gload 1
55 30 Cristhian Mart?*nez 2
56 30 Chris Leroux 2
57 29.4 Esmerling Vásquez 14.1
58 29 Kris Medlen 8.1
59 28.8 Doug Slaten 5.2
60 28.5 Garrett Mock 13
61 28.4 Hong-Chih Kuo 5.1
62 28.3 Tyler Yates 12
63 28.1 Matt Capps 15.1
64 27.7 Will Ohman 12.1
65 27.4 Jeff Samardzija 3.1
66 27.3 Joe Martinez 2.2
67 26.9 Wil Ledezma 5.2
68 26.6 Billy Buckner 11.1
69 26.5 Wesley Wright 13.2
70 26 Matt Belisle 17.1
71 25.8 Alan Embree 12
72 25.7 Bryan Augenstein 11.1
73 25 Mike Hinckley 9.2
74 24.2 Jorge Campillo 3.1
75 24.2 Eulogio De La Cruz 3.1
76 23.8 Scott Elbert 6.1
77 23.6 Neal Cotts 11
78 23.2 Donnie Veal 4.1
79 22.8 Walter Silva 9.2
80 22.3 Saul Rivera 11.2
81 22.3 P.J. Walters 10.1
82 22.2 Oliver Pérez 0
83 21.7 Osiris Matos 6
84 21.4 Carlos Mart?*nez 2.1
85 20.7 Andrew Carpenter 4.1
86 20 Graham Taylor 11
87 19.2 Doug Brocail 5.2
88 19 Logan Kensing 7.1
89 16.7 Alex Hinshaw 5.1
90 15.9 Homer Bailey 4.1
91 15 Bobby Korecky 6
92 13.3 Jesús Colome 3
93 12.7 Duaner Sánchez 11
94 10 Brandon Webb 4
95 9.1 R.J. Swindle 2.2
96 8.1 Pat Misch 3.1
97 6.3 John Koronka 7.1
98 -2 Logan Kensing 5
99 -9.1 Josh Kinney 2.2
100 -10 David Riske 1
101 -33.3 Tom Gordon 1.2
102 -40.5 Arturo Lopez 2.1
103 -40.9 Blaine Boyer 1.1
104 -50 Paul Janish 1
105 -50 Dave Davidson 1
I'll also list my bullpen rankings based on the same formula.
I've found them to be a key in my line projections and handicapping.
The individuals are listed in 3 categories based on innings pitched. Stats through Tuesday's games, May 26.
Bullpen
1 Boston 40.7
2 Milwaukee 40.4
3 Oakland 39.8
4 St. Louis 39.6
5 Toronto 39.1
6 NY Mets 39
7 LA Dodgers 38.6
8 Philadelphia 38.3
9 Kansas City 38.2
10 Atlanta 38.1
11 Florida 38
12 Cincinnati 38
13 San Diego 37.7
14 Chicago Sox 37.1
15 San Francisco 37
16 Seattle 36.3
17 Tampa Bay 36.1
18 Pittsburgh 35.8
19 Chicago Cubs 35.8
20 Detroit 35.7
21 Minnesota 34.7
22 Arizona 34.7
23 Baltimore 34.6
24 Houston 34.3
25 Cleveland 34.2
26 NY Yankees 33.8
27 Colorado 33.8
28 LA Angels 33.1
29 Texas 32.9
30 Washington 31.5
American League
Individual Pitcher Rating
Category 1
IP > Team Games
Rank Rating Player IP
1 51.1 Zack Greinke 75
2 47.5 Justin Verlander 63.1
3 44 Roy Halladay 75
4 43.9 Erik Bedard 47.2
5 42 Edwin Jackson 66.1
6 41.5 Jered Weaver 60.2
7 41.2 Matt Garza 66.2
8 41.1 Felix Hernandez 64.2
9 40.7 CC Sabathia 71
10 39.5 Mark Buehrle 59
11 39.5 Jarrod Washburn 57.1
12 39 Cliff Lee 68
13 38.5 Scott Richmond 52
14 38.4 Koji Uehara 50.2
15 37.6 John Danks 49
16 37.4 Brian Tallet 54.1
17 36.9 Rick Porcello 45.2
18 36.9 Gil Meche 55.1
19 36.7 Joe Saunders 66.1
20 36.7 James Shields 67
21 36.5 Kevin Millwood 72
22 36.4 Kyle Davies 52.2
23 36.4 Josh Beckett 55.2
24 36.3 Tim Wakefield 58.2
25 36.2 Nick Blackburn 63.1
26 35.9 Dallas Braden 61
27 35.7 Carl Pavano 55.2
28 35.5 Kevin Slowey 55.1
29 35 A.J. Burnett 58
30 34.7 Bartolo Colon 45
31 34.1 Vicente Padilla 49.2
32 34.1 Brandon McCarthy 54
33 34 Andy Pettitte 58.2
34 33.9 Jon Lester 59.1
35 33.8 Glen Perkins 47
36 32.8 Francisco Liriano 54.2
37 32.6 Scott Baker 47
38 32.6 Jeremy Guthrie 60.2
39 32 Gavin Floyd 52.1
40 31.9 Brett Anderson 43.1
41 31.7 Armando Galarraga 47
42 31.2 Matt Harrison 54.2
43 30.9 Brad Penny 48.1
44 30.3 Trevor Cahill 48.2
45 30.3 Fausto Carmona 54.2
Category 2
IP < Team Games &
> Team Games/ 3
1 51.9 Frank Francisco 16.2
2 49 Andrew Bailey 29.2
3 48.5 Scott Downs 20.1
4 47.6 David Aardsma 21.2
5 47.4 Michael Wuertz 23
6 46.7 Ramon Ramirez 24.1
7 46.7 Matt Thornton 18.1
8 46 Octavio Dotel 15.1
9 46 Hideki Okajima 20
10 45.3 Robinson Tejeda 17
11 44.8 Manny Delcarmen 21
12 44.5 J.P. Howell 22
13 44.2 Joe Nathan 17.1
14 43.8 Jason Frasor 16.2
15 43.2 Ryan Perry 19.1
16 43.2 Mariano Rivera 19.2
17 42.9 Scott Linebrink 17
18 42.5 Darren Oliver 21.2
19 42 Alfredo Aceves 16.2
20 41.9 Jonathan Papelbon 21
21 41.7 George Sherrill 19.2
22 41.7 Fernando Rodney 18
23 41.4 Jason Vargas 21
24 41.3 Kyle Farnsworth 16
25 41.3 Danys Baez 24.2
26 40.9 Matt Guerrier 23.1
27 40.7 Brian Fuentes 16.2
28 40.6 Takashi Saito 17
29 40.5 Juan Cruz 20
30 40.3 Lance Cormier 34
31 40.1 Jesse Carlson 25.2
32 40 Jose Arredondo 21
33 39.7 Rafael Betancourt 25.2
34 39.5 Josh Outman 40.1
35 39.1 D.J. Carrasco 31.2
36 39 Santiago Casilla 18.1
37 39 Brian Bannister 42
38 38.8 Bobby Jenks 16
39 38.6 Brandon League 20.2
40 38 Justin Masterson 44.1
41 37.4 Joba Chamberlain 45.1
42 37.4 Jim Johnson 23.1
43 37.3 Sean White 22.1
44 37.2 Scott Feldman 42.1
45 36.7 Miguel Batista 24
46 36.6 Jamey Wright 23.1
47 36.2 Ricky Romero 26.1
48 36.1 Clayton Richard 33
49 36 Jason Bulger 17.2
50 36 Dontrelle Willis 17.2
51 35.6 Justin Speier 18.1
52 35.6 Jason Jennings 20.1
53 35.6 Aaron Laffey 34.1
54 35.3 Brad Ziegler 19.1
55 35.2 Matt Palmer 37.1
56 35.2 Dan Wheeler 16.2
57 35.2 C.J. Wilson 18.2
58 35.1 Robert Ray 24.1
59 35.1 Grant Balfour 20.1
60 34.8 Jose Veras 19.1
61 34.4 Brian Bass 30.1
62 34.1 Phil Coke 20.1
63 33.6 Mark Lowe 23.2
64 33.5 Derek Holland 18.2
65 33.3 Ron Mahay 16.2
66 33.1 R.A. Dickey 26.1
67 33 Russ Springer 17.1
68 32.9 Phil Hughes 29.2
69 32.6 Jensen Lewis 24.2
70 32.6 Brett Cecil 24.2
71 32.5 Lance Broadway 16
72 32.5 Kerry Wood 16
73 32.3 Garrett Olson 19.2
74 31.7 Luis Ayala 20.2
75 31.6 Jeff Niemann 47.2
76 31.1 Zach Miner 28.1
77 31 David Purcey 25.2
78 30.5 Joe Nelson 19
79 30.5 Dan Giese 22
80 30.2 Sidney Ponson 43
81 30.2 Shawn Camp 16.2
82 30.2 Scot Shields 17.2
83 30 Mark Hendrickson 34
84 29.9 Chris Jakubauskas 44.2
85 29.3 Shane Loux 38.1
86 29.3 Brad Bergesen 39.1
87 29.3 Anthony Reyes 38.1
88 29 Andy Sonnanstine 46.1
89 28.1 Jonathan Albaladejo 21
90 27.2 Edwar Ram?*rez 17.1
91 26.7 Brandon Lyon 21
92 26.3 Scott Kazmir 45.2
93 25.7 Horacio Ramirez 18.1
94 24.7 Jose Contreras 29.2
95 24.6 Adam Eaton 41
96 23.8 Carlos Silva 28.2
97 22.6 Dana Eveland 24.1
98 21.1 Kris Benson 18
Category 3
IP < Team Games/3
1 70 Romon Colon 1
2 68.2 John Bale 1.1
3 60 Michael Bowden 2
4 55.6 Brian Bruney 9
5 50 Luke French 3
6 50 Jeff Gray 0.1
7 48.2 Matt Herges 11.2
8 47.5 Darren O'Day 12
9 46.7 Craig Breslow 3
10 46.4 Kevin Cameron 14
11 46.2 David Robertson 5.2
12 45.1 Joakim Soria 8.2
13 45.1 Brian Wolfe 6.1
14 44.3 Anthony Swarzak 7
15 44 Edgar González 5
16 43.8 Shawn Kelley 11.2
17 42.9 José Mijares 14
18 41.7 Nick Adenhart 6
19 41.6 Joel Zumaya 13.1
20 41 Rich Hill 11.1
21 40.1 Bobby Seay 13.1
22 40 Rich Rundles 1
23 40 Randy Choate 2
24 40 Nick Swisher 1
25 40 Greg Aquino 5
26 39.2 Bill Murphy 11.1
27 38.1 Zach Jackson 4.2
28 36.7 Daniel Bard 6
29 36 Nate Robertson 12.1
30 35.8 John Lackey 12
31 35.1 Brian Shouse 14.1
32 33.9 Rich Thompson 3.1
33 33.6 Tony Sipp 6.1
34 33.3 Matt Albers 13.2
35 33.3 Bryan Bullington 6
36 33.3 Brian Duensing 3
37 33 Jamie Walker 10
38 32.2 Juan Rincón 10.1
39 32 Joe Smith 6.1
40 32 Jason Berken 5
41 31.6 Brandon Morrow 14.1
42 31.3 Sean Henn 3.2
43 30.9 Craig Breslow 14.1
44 30.8 Vinnie Chulk 12
45 30.3 Dustin Moseley 14.2
46 30 Casey Janssen 6
47 29.5 Dennis Sarfate 12.2
48 28.9 Hunter Jones 9
49 28.5 Jesse Crain 13
50 28 Gio González 8.2
51 27.5 Doug Waechter 4
52 27.4 Ryan Rowland-Smith 3.1
53 27.4 Mark Melancon 3.1
54 27.4 David Price 3.1
55 26.7 Jason Isringhausen 3
56 26.6 Troy Percival 11.1
57 26.6 Sean Gallagher 0
58 26.2 Warner Madrigal 4.2
59 25.6 Willie Eyre 4.1
60 25 Eddie Guardado 9.2
61 24.6 Ervin Santana 12.2
62 24.2 Luis Vizca?*no 3.1
63 24 Denny Stark 10
64 24 Bob McCrory 5
65 23.6 Jeremy Sowers 14
66 23.3 Jesse Litsch 9
67 23.2 Brett Tomko 4.1
68 22.8 Masa Kobayashi 9.2
69 22.3 B.J. Ryan 10.1
70 22.1 Rafael Rodr?*guez 14
71 21.8 Chris Ray 13.1
72 20.7 Dale Thayer 4.1
73 19.5 Roy Corcoran 8.2
74 18.3 Scott Lewis 4.1
75 18.3 Jimmy Gobble 4.1
76 18 Anthony Ortega 12.2
77 16.3 Eddie Bonine 8
78 16.1 Javier López 11.2
79 15.8 Daisuke Matsuzaka 11.1
80 15.2 Luke Hochevar 11.2
81 13.4 Jerry Blevins 0
82 12.3 Brian Burres 6.1
83 11.9 Clay Rapada 2.1
84 10.7 Alfredo Simon 6.1
85 8.8 Dámaso Marte 5.1
86 8.5 Mike MacDougal 4.1
87 7.8 Rafael Pérez 10.2
88 6.1 Philip Humber 4.1
89 -8.3 Daniel Davidson 1.2
90 -9.5 Kevin Jepsen 4.2
91 -10 Juan Morillo 0
92 -14.3 Josh Rupe 4.2
93 -20 Chien-Ming Wang 9
94 -40 Luis Mendoza 1
95 -40.9 Jack Egbert 2.2
96 -50 Jonathan Van Every 0.2
97 -125 Anthony Claggett 1.2
98 -140.9 Radhames Liz 1.1
99 -250 Fernando Rodr?*guez 0.2
National League
Individual Pitcher Rating
Category 1
IP > Team Games
Rank Rating Player IP
1 49 Johan Santana 60
2 47.2 Tim Lincecum 65.1
3 45.6 Dan Haren 63
4 45.4 Wandy Rodriguez 63
5 44.9 Chad Billingsley 67
6 44.8 Jake Peavy 67.1
7 44.7 Javier Vazquez 64
8 43.6 Josh Johnson 67.1
9 43 Johnny Cueto 60.2
10 42.9 Yovani Gallardo 59.2
11 41.6 Max Scherzer 50.2
12 41.2 Randy Wolf 62.2
13 41 Clayton Kershaw 50
14 40.9 Zach Duke 65
15 40.7 Jair Jurrjens 61
16 40.6 Adam Wainwright 65
17 39.9 Derek Lowe 62.2
18 39.7 Aaron Harang 64.1
19 39.5 Ted Lilly 57.1
20 39.4 Ubaldo Jiminez 53
21 39.4 Jorge De La Rosa 49.2
22 39.3 Chris Volstad 61
23 39 Matt Cain 60
24 39 Edinson Volquez 48.2
25 38.7 Kyle Lohse 54.1
26 37.8 Dave Bush 59.2
27 37.6 Kenshin Kawakami 45.2
28 37.1 Doug Davis 62
29 36.9 Joel Pinieiro 61.1
30 36.8 Barry Zito 56
31 36.7 Ryan Dempster 61.1
32 36.7 John Maine 51.2
33 36.6 Paul Maholm 61.1
34 36.5 Chris Young 56.2
35 35.5 Ross Ohlendorf 55.2
36 35.2 Roy Oswalt 62.1
37 34.7 Kevin Correia 49.1
38 34.6 Jason Marquis 60.2
39 34.1 Livan Hernandez 54.2
40 34 Brett Myers 58
41 33.7 Randy Johnson 46
42 33.6 Shairon Martis 53.2
43 33.2 Joe Blanton 51.1
44 33.1 Micah Owings 49
45 33 Ian Snell 53
46 32.7 Manny Parra 46.2
47 32.5 Mike Pelfrey 48
48 32.1 Mike Hampton 48
49 32.1 John Lannan 57
50 32 Braden Looper 50.1
51 32 Aaron Cook 56
52 31.7 Todd Wellemeyer 52
53 30.3 Jon Garland 53.2
54 29.6 Bronson Arroyo 56
55 28.9 Jeff Suppan 53.1
56 23.9 Jamie Moyer 47.1
Category 2
IP < Team Games &
> Team Games/ 3
1 57.8 Jonathan Broxton 23
2 53.9 Chris Carpenter 23
3 53.1 Heath Bell 19.1
4 52.1 Rafael Soriano 19.2
5 49.1 Kiko Calero 22.1
6 48.1 Mark DiFelice 21.2
7 48 Nick Masset 15.2
8 47.6 Francisco Rodriguez 21.2
9 47.5 Eric O'Flaherty 16.2
10 47.5 Arthur Rhodes 16
11 46.8 Ryan Madson 22.1
12 46.7 Francisco Cordero 21
13 46.5 Ryan Franklin 17.2
14 46.1 Randy Wells 18
15 45.7 Edward Mujica 23.1
16 45.5 Angel Guzman 20
17 45.3 Dan Meyer 19.2
18 44.3 Jesse Chavez 19.2
19 43.9 Pedro Feliciano 18.1
20 43.7 Mike Gonzalez 19
21 43.7 Carlos Villanueva 22.2
22 43.4 J.A. Happ 27.2
23 43 Luke Gregerson 27.1
24 43 Kyle McClellan 23
25 43 Chad Qualls 20
26 42.8 Huston Street 18.1
27 42.7 Juan Gutierrez 26.1
28 42.6 Ronald Belisario 27.2
29 42.4 Ramon Troncoso 30.1
30 42.2 Jason Motte 18
31 41.9 Tony Pena 22.1
32 41.5 Jeremy Affeldt 21.1
33 41.5 Carlos Marmol 20
34 41.4 Justin Miller 21
35 41.3 Jeff Fulchino 17.2
36 41.1 LaTroy Hawkins 19.2
37 40.5 Sean Burnett 21
38 40.5 Clay Condrey 24.2
39 40.1 Daniel Ray Herrera 17.2
40 40 Todd Coffey 22
41 40 Leo Nunez 23.1
42 40 Chris Sampson 28
43 39.6 Brian Wilson 21.1
44 39.6 Bobby Parnell 19.2
45 39.4 Rich Harden 43.2
46 38.9 David Weathers 16.2
47 38.6 Renyel Pinto 21.1
48 38.4 J.J. Putz 25.1
49 38.1 Brandon Medders 20.1
50 37.9 Carlos Zambrano 42.2
51 37.6 Jeff Bennett 21
52 37.6 Chad Durbin 25.1
53 37.4 Seth McClung 23.1
54 37.4 Jonathan Sanchez 43
55 37.2 Bob Howry 18
56 37.1 Tim Byrdak 17
57 37.1 Sean Marshall 41.1
58 36.9 Mitchell Boggs 22.1
59 36.8 Peter Moylan 15.2
60 36.7 Joel Hanrahan 21.1
61 36.7 Cole Hamels 42.1
62 36.4 Jeff Weaver 22.1
63 36.3 Julian Tavarez 19
64 36.3 Brian Stokes 18.2
65 36.2 Evan Meek 15.2
66 36.1 Jordan Zimmermann 41
67 35.7 Eric Stults 42
68 35.5 Chad Gaudin 33.1
69 35.1 Cla Meredith 16.1
70 35 Kip Wells 22
71 34.9 Andrew Miller 29.2
72 34.6 Burke Badenhop 20.1
73 34.5 Jason Grilli 16.1
74 34.3 John Grabow 21
75 34.2 Matt Lindstrom 19
76 34 Kevin Gregg 18.1
77 33.5 Josh Geer 40.1
78 33 Jorge Julio 17.1
79 32.7 Jason Hammel 37.1
80 32.3 Jack Taschner 19.2
81 32.2 Jo-Jo Reyes 27
82 32.1 Manuel Corpas 21.2
83 31.8 Aaron Heilman 19.2
84 31.7 Russ Ortiz 31.1
85 31.7 Joe Beimel 18
86 31.7 Jared Burton 20.2
87 31.7 Hayden Penn 20.2
88 31.3 Edwin Moreno 17.1
89 30.7 Jeff Karstens 43.1
90 30.1 Chan Ho Park 38.1
91 29.5 Anibal Sanchez 32.2
92 27.9 Sean Green 18.1
93 27.3 Felipe Paulino 30
94 26.9 James McDonald 18.2
95 26.4 Ricky Nolasco 43.2
96 26.1 Scott Olsen 41
97 25.8 Jon Rauch 18.2
98 25.8 Brian Moehler 26
99 25.3 Glendon Rusch 18.2
100 24.8 Daniel Cabrera 40
101 24.4 Yusmeiro Petit 24.2
102 24.4 Guillermo Mota 18
103 24.1 Brad Lidge 20.1
104 23 Geoff Geary 20
105 20.2 Buddy Carlyle 19.1
106 15 Mike Lincoln 16
Category 3
IP < Team Games/3
1 56.3 Randy Flores 3.2
2 55.9 Greg Burke 5.1
3 55 Clay Zavada 2
4 54.8 Sergio Escalona 2.1
5 53.8 Trevor Hoffman 13
6 53.1 Luis Vizca?*no 3.2
7 51.7 Brian Sanches 6
8 50 Manny Acosta 2
9 50 Josh Fogg 2
10 50 Joe Thatcher 1.2
11 46.4 Ross Detwiler 11
12 43.7 Ron Villone 11.1
13 43.5 José Ascanio 6.2
14 43.1 Chris Pérez 13.1
15 42.7 Matt Daley 8.2
16 42.3 Hiroki Kuroda 5.2
17 42 Tom Gorzelanny 5
18 41.6 Dennys Reyes 13.1
19 41 Trever Miller 11.1
20 40.3 Leo Rosales 7.2
21 40.1 Alberto Arias 9.1
22 40 Sean West 5
23 40 Josh Wilson 1
24 40 Franklin Morales 8
25 40 Cody Ross 1
26 40 Carlos Fisher 3
27 38.3 Brent Leach 6
28 37.5 José Valverde 8
29 37.5 Joel Peralta 3.2
30 37.3 Jonathon Niese 10.2
31 37.1 Merkin Valdez 13.2
32 36.8 Ken Takahashi 9.1
33 36.7 Eric Milton 9
34 36.7 Darren O'Day 3
35 36.6 Blaine Boyer 8.2
36 36.3 Mitch Stetter 13.1
37 36 Steven Shell 5
38 35.7 Ramon Ramirez 2.1
39 35.2 Brad Thompson 14.2
40 35.1 Scott Eyre 10.1
41 35 Nelson Figueroa 6
42 35 James Parr 14
43 35 Casey Fossum 4
44 34.3 Scott Schoeneweis 10.2
45 33.8 Craig Stammen 11.1
46 33.4 Luis Perdomo 15.1
47 33.3 Shawn Hill 12
48 32.2 Cory Wade 15.2
49 32 Craig Hansen 6.1
50 31.5 Jason Bergmann 8.1
51 30.8 Ryan Speier 5.2
52 30.4 Tim Redding 10.2
53 30.1 David Patton 14.1
54 30 Ross Gload 1
55 30 Cristhian Mart?*nez 2
56 30 Chris Leroux 2
57 29.4 Esmerling Vásquez 14.1
58 29 Kris Medlen 8.1
59 28.8 Doug Slaten 5.2
60 28.5 Garrett Mock 13
61 28.4 Hong-Chih Kuo 5.1
62 28.3 Tyler Yates 12
63 28.1 Matt Capps 15.1
64 27.7 Will Ohman 12.1
65 27.4 Jeff Samardzija 3.1
66 27.3 Joe Martinez 2.2
67 26.9 Wil Ledezma 5.2
68 26.6 Billy Buckner 11.1
69 26.5 Wesley Wright 13.2
70 26 Matt Belisle 17.1
71 25.8 Alan Embree 12
72 25.7 Bryan Augenstein 11.1
73 25 Mike Hinckley 9.2
74 24.2 Jorge Campillo 3.1
75 24.2 Eulogio De La Cruz 3.1
76 23.8 Scott Elbert 6.1
77 23.6 Neal Cotts 11
78 23.2 Donnie Veal 4.1
79 22.8 Walter Silva 9.2
80 22.3 Saul Rivera 11.2
81 22.3 P.J. Walters 10.1
82 22.2 Oliver Pérez 0
83 21.7 Osiris Matos 6
84 21.4 Carlos Mart?*nez 2.1
85 20.7 Andrew Carpenter 4.1
86 20 Graham Taylor 11
87 19.2 Doug Brocail 5.2
88 19 Logan Kensing 7.1
89 16.7 Alex Hinshaw 5.1
90 15.9 Homer Bailey 4.1
91 15 Bobby Korecky 6
92 13.3 Jesús Colome 3
93 12.7 Duaner Sánchez 11
94 10 Brandon Webb 4
95 9.1 R.J. Swindle 2.2
96 8.1 Pat Misch 3.1
97 6.3 John Koronka 7.1
98 -2 Logan Kensing 5
99 -9.1 Josh Kinney 2.2
100 -10 David Riske 1
101 -33.3 Tom Gordon 1.2
102 -40.5 Arturo Lopez 2.1
103 -40.9 Blaine Boyer 1.1
104 -50 Paul Janish 1
105 -50 Dave Davidson 1
