Trade Help

[Bennymac17]

10-team non keeper league, and this was proposed to me today...

GET:

Ryan Braun
Curtis Granderson
Michael Young

GIVE UP:

Roy Halladay
Justin Upton
Alex Rodriguez


Essentially it his his top 3 guys vs. my top 3 guys. Any input is appreciated.

 

[Trampled Underfoot]

10-team non keeper league, and this was proposed to me today...

GET:

Ryan Braun
Curtis Granderson
Michael Young

GIVE UP:

Roy Halladay
Justin Upton
Alex Rodriguez


Essentially it his his top 3 guys vs. my top 3 guys. Any input is appreciated.

Before the injury to Arod, I would have just kept the three you had.

 

[Bennymac17]

Before the injury to Arod, I would have just kept the three you had.

Thanks. The other guy canceled that trade pretty quickly. Hopefully A-Rod isn't out the full 6 weeks.

 

[Dr Feelgood]

H2H or Roti league or 5X5?

I would never trade Halladay..hands down the most consistent pitcher in baseball....Grandy and Young are on one year and off the next (Young only hists for avg)....

you're better off with what you have...