What's your favorite fish to eat and why?

MadJack

Administrator
Staff member
Forum Admin
Super Moderators
Channel Owner
Jul 13, 1999
104,765
1,402
113
69
home
I'm trying to develop a taste for fish, I never really cared for it but recently had a couple dinners that were pretty good so want to try more. I definitely don't want any bony fish, don't want to deal with it, or fish with a strong seafood taste. I think the best I ever had was at a restaurant in Minnesota that served Walleye as their specialty. Blackened orange roughy was good, grouper decent, I like the texture of the haddock I've had. Any suggestions?

Maybe some fish you like to cook at home with recipe would be helpful as well.

:0008
 

Mags

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 8, 2000
2,813
27
48
I'm trying to develop a taste for fish, I never really cared for it but recently had a couple dinners that were pretty good so want to try more. I definitely don't want any bony fish, don't want to deal with it, or fish with a strong seafood taste. I think the best I ever had was at a restaurant in Minnesota that served Walleye as their specialty. Blackened orange roughy was good, grouper decent, I like the texture of the haddock I've had. Any suggestions?

Maybe some fish you like to cook at home with recipe would be helpful as well.

:0008

Jack, you have to get up to Wisconsin some time. Friday nights, every restaurant has a "Friday Fish Fry". Usually beer battered cod or haddock (all you can eat), but sometimes you can find perch and walleye also. Some places will have blue gills also. All outstanding!

Getting away from fried fish (and eating healthy), there are a number of outstanding fish that you don't deep fry - many you can put right on the grill (best to have aluminum foil or a grill mat so it doesn't fall through the grates):

Salmon on a cedar plank: the plank will give the salmon a smoky flavor - outstanding. Salmon is "beefier" than some fish, but very tasty.

Tilapia is inexpensive and very mild. A good tasting fish, but must season it (Old Bay)

Grouper and Orange Roughy are both good too.

My favorite (but pricy) is Chilean Sea Bass. It is a "Meatier" white fish with its own oils, so it is always very moist when cooked. Outstanding - expensive in restaurants. When buying it in a store (like a Whole Foods or something like that), always ask to smell it before purchasing, as sometimes it can get a fishy smell - which is not good.

Good luck on your dive into fish (get it, dive in?)
 

MadJack

Administrator
Staff member
Forum Admin
Super Moderators
Channel Owner
Jul 13, 1999
104,765
1,402
113
69
home
Jack, you have to get up to Wisconsin some time. Friday nights, every restaurant has a "Friday Fish Fry". Usually beer battered cod or haddock (all you can eat), but sometimes you can find perch and walleye also. Some places will have blue gills also. All outstanding!

Getting away from fried fish (and eating healthy), there are a number of outstanding fish that you don't deep fry - many you can put right on the grill (best to have aluminum foil or a grill mat so it doesn't fall through the grates):

Salmon on a cedar plank: the plank will give the salmon a smoky flavor - outstanding. Salmon is "beefier" than some fish, but very tasty.

Tilapia is inexpensive and very mild. A good tasting fish, but must season it (Old Bay)

Grouper and Orange Roughy are both good too.

My favorite (but pricy) is Chilean Sea Bass. It is a "Meatier" white fish with its own oils, so it is always very moist when cooked. Outstanding - expensive in restaurants. When buying it in a store (like a Whole Foods or something like that), always ask to smell it before purchasing, as sometimes it can get a fishy smell - which is not good.

Good luck on your dive into fish (get it, dive in?)

Perch and trout are tasty but have the bones I don't want to deal with. Have had swordfish years ago and remember it was good. Same as tuna. The standout from my limited fish eating experience was walleye about 20 years ago. I still rate that dinner in my top 10 ever. That was in Minnesota. There was a fish that was very good when I was in Tampa Bay, it's big down there, but I don't remember what it's called. My last trip to Costa Rica they served haddock on the plane and it was great. And that was plane food, I imagine a good restaurant would blow that away. Never tried the Chilean Sea Bass.

I have to start a healthier diet. I'm late but it's never too late.

:0008
 

Mags

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 8, 2000
2,813
27
48
Perch and trout are tasty but have the bones I don't want to deal with. Have had swordfish years ago and remember it was good. Same as tuna. The standout from my limited fish eating experience was walleye about 20 years ago. I still rate that dinner in my top 10 ever. That was in Minnesota. There was a fish that was very good when I was in Tampa Bay, it's big down there, but I don't remember what it's called. My last trip to Costa Rica they served haddock on the plane and it was great. And that was plane food, I imagine a good restaurant would blow that away. Never tried the Chilean Sea Bass.

I have to start a healthier diet. I'm late but it's never too late.

:0008

True, fish is very good for the diet.

Not sure where you are getting bones in perch. Never had one in all my years of fish fries in Wisconsin. Probably comes down to who is prepping the fish.

Funny you mention Tampa - that is where I am right now. I'm guessing you had grouper down here - most of the restaurants have a grouper sandwich, and it is usually very good.

Try some salmon on a cedar plank (easy to do at home). Lightly dust with some Old Bay (or any other seasoning you prefer). Put on the grill. Easy to cook. Will turn out great!
 

MadJack

Administrator
Staff member
Forum Admin
Super Moderators
Channel Owner
Jul 13, 1999
104,765
1,402
113
69
home
True, fish is very good for the diet.

Not sure where you are getting bones in perch. Never had one in all my years of fish fries in Wisconsin. Probably comes down to who is prepping the fish.

Funny you mention Tampa - that is where I am right now. I'm guessing you had grouper down here - most of the restaurants have a grouper sandwich, and it is usually very good.

Try some salmon on a cedar plank (easy to do at home). Lightly dust with some Old Bay (or any other seasoning you prefer). Put on the grill. Easy to cook. Will turn out great!

Maybe it was grouper, I just don't remember. It was fried though and not usually crazy about anything fried. I'll try salmon the next chance I get.
 

hedgehog

Registered
Forum Member
Oct 30, 2003
32,692
599
113
49
TX
Wife and I eat rainbow trout or salmon, cooked in foil in the oven seasoned with lemon pepper and olive oil...I cut up a lemon and squeeze on mine after it cools off out of the oven, out of this world good. I bet it would be great on the egg grill too :0008
 

Salty

Registered
Forum Member
Sep 10, 2015
2,052
26
0
Halal Pork Delicatessen
Salmon is very fishy imo. Careful with that one and definitely don't try it smoked for the first time if your worried about fishiness. Tilapia is kinda like the McDonalds of fish today.... Definitely can't go wrong with a good Chilean seabass. Black cod is very tasty imo. Also anytime I see red fish on a menu its ordered no matter what.
 

Salty

Registered
Forum Member
Sep 10, 2015
2,052
26
0
Halal Pork Delicatessen
I just read your full post up there... I love orange roughy. Another tasty fish imo that's not to strong is mahi mahi. Usually find that in tacos. Bust again usually raised in a farm.


One thing I absolutely hate, a farm raised fish.
 

StevieD

Registered User
Forum Member
Jun 18, 2002
9,509
44
48
72
Boston
I like cod or haddock. I can't tell the difference between cod and haddock myself but I like them both. White fish without a strong "fishy" taste.
 
Last edited:

redsfann

ale connoisseur
Forum Member
Aug 3, 1999
9,087
294
83
60
Somewhere in Corn Country
What's your favorite fish to eat and why?

Swordfish.
Marinate it for 1/2 hour in a 50/50 mixture of Italian dressing and soy sauce. Don?t over marinate as the soy sauce will start cooking the fish.
Over red hot coals grill for 2-3 minutes a side being careful to leave at least a little pink inside.
I usually eat my swordfish medium rare like my steaks but as long as you don?t cook it until it well done it will be fantastic


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

redsfann

ale connoisseur
Forum Member
Aug 3, 1999
9,087
294
83
60
Somewhere in Corn Country
Alaskan halibut is amazing too, but very pricey.
My fishing buddies always have a huge fish fry once a summer. Catfish, trout, bluegill, stripies?all locally caught in the rivers and lakes of Iowa.
Everyone brings sides to share and the party goes on all day. [emoji41]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Keyser Soze

Registered User
Forum Member
Jan 20, 2000
2,284
60
48
Orlando
I eat fish 3/4 times a week. Already mentioned, but Chilean Sea Bass and Halibut are my two favs. Don't have them all that often because they are quite $$$$$$

Make swordfish a lot. Very simple. I bake it with some fresh cracked pepper on top a spritz of lemon juice and I take a couple of thinly sliced pieces of honey butter and place them on top before placing it in the oven. It melts as it cooks and seeps into the fish as well as creating a bit of a golden crust on top.
 

Betone

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 24, 2004
16,254
278
83
65
Monument, CO
My favorite fish is Ahi Tuna , seasoned with steak rub seared about 2 minutes on each side, medium rare. Dip in soy sauce .... it?s just as tasty as a good steak to me! I still force myself to eat Salmon once every couple weeks, heavy on the old bay and hot sauce. Wild Salmon only.....
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top