I've been doing pretty well with them since the all-star break. Also, when I saw their schedule in July and August I also threw a little bit on them to win the world series +1300... that would be nice!
NYY is the worst $$ team vs the betting line this year - -$1811 (if you bet $100 every game on a dime line.) They are +$252 vs. the RunLine on the year.
They are usually overpriced because of public perception and have underperformed as they were +/- 98 Wins on total wins to begin year. I expect them to make the playoffs and I would play them on the RL going forward if you are thinking about riding them or at least when they are laying a steep price play the RL.