Sports network
Sports network
Philadelphia, PA (SportsNetwork.com) - North Dakota State's national championship-winning defense has been the standard across the FCS throughout the decade.
The best in show, if you will.
In contrast, Illinois State likes to claim it unleashes a pack of mutts on game day.
But the Missouri Valley Football Conference co-champions will bring both bark and bite to the national dog show, er, NCAA Division I Football Championship Game Saturday at Toyota Stadium in Frisco, Texas (ESPN2, 1 p.m. ET).
Yes, beware of defense. The championship game is expected to be a bruising matchup of stopping the run and pounding the other into mission. North Dakota State is seeking an unprecedented fourth straight FCS title while Illinois State will try to end the Bison dynasty in its first championship game appearance.
The two defenses might have different pedigrees, but both 4-3 systems are linked by having new defensive coordinators and mixing in new contributors with veteran standouts.
North Dakota State led the FCS in scoring defense in each of its championship years and this season the team ranks second nationally behind Harvard in allowing 13.2 points per game. The Bison (14-1), who feature the national defensive player of the year in Buck Buchanan Award-winning defensive end Kyle Emanuel, also rank third in total defense, allowing opponents just 270.8 yards per game.
Illinois State's more balanced defense has allowed 20.9 points and 337.6 yards per game - not the NDSU standard, of course, but still impressive numbers while playing in the nation's top FCS conference.
"I think when we play together, we're very good. If we don't play together, we're just average. We're a pack of mutts, we're not a bunch of purebreds," said Illinois State coach Brock Spack, whose defense has helped take down a murderer's row of offenses in Northern Iowa, Eastern Washington and New Hampshire during the postseason.
Spack, who was the defensive coordinator at his alma mater, Purdue, from 1997-2008, is in his sixth season as Illinois State's head coach. He had been coordinating the Redbirds defense in recent seasons until he began to hand the duties over to defensive line coach Spence Nowinsky during the 2013 season. Right after the 5-6 campaign, Spack handed Nowinsky the keys to the defense.
The Redbirds have rebounded to go 13-1 and play with a relentless, physical style on defense, featuring All-Missouri Valley first-team selections Pat Meehan, a middle linebacker, and Teddy Corwin, a defensive end. The defense has two FBS transfers in defensive end David Perkins (Ohio State) and outside linebacker Oshay Dunmore (Oregon). Senior linebacker Mike Banks is the unit's most experienced player, going into his 50th and final start.
"Spence has done a great job, along with obviously the rest of our defensive staff," Spack said.
"So the guys understand the system, they understand there is a protocol which we install our system, there's a protocol how we game plan ... and I've kind of stuck to that, and they learned it, and now that's kind of what they do. They have their own little tweaks to things, as they should, and they've done a great job. The system is in place, and I felt that I could step away, and I'm still in that room almost exclusively, but I'm in the room a lot. They lean on me for advice, and I'm there if they need it, and I'll chime in when I feel it's necessary, but I've enjoyed being a head coach - this is my sixth year - more than I have the five previous years."
Chris Klieman arrived at North Dakota State also after coaching at his alma mater, Northern Iowa. He joined the Bison in their first national championship season in 2011 as their defensive backs coach and then served as defensive coordinator the last two seasons. After Craig Bohl departed to become Wyoming's head coach last January, NDSU wisely elevated Klieman to the top job. He later brought Matt Entz over from Western Illinois to become defensive coordinator.
Including Emanuel, who has the most tackles for loss (31) and sacks (19.5) in the FCS, the Bison returned six starters and seven of their top nine tacklers from last season. They rebuilt the interior of the defensive line with junior Brian Schaetz and redshirt freshman Nate Tanguay, and reloaded on the back end with the likes of linebacker Carlton Littlejohn and Esley Thornton and safeties Colten Heagle and Christian Dudzik, who has yet to miss a start as he enters his 60th and final game.
Entz, Klieman said, "had to leave a really good job with Coach (Bob) Nielson at Western Illinois to come to Fargo with his family and take a chance, and he did that, and he's done a remarkable job of being Matt Entz, of not trying to be anything that I was or Scottie Hazelton was before, similar to myself, trying to make my own niche, Matt has made his own niche, and the guys love to play for him. He's done a great job of game planning each week as well as our other defensive staff members, and couldn't be happier to have Matt on my staff for the long haul.
"Well, he didn't want to reinvent the wheel ... it's not like we've done a bunch of different things schematically, I think it's just his demeanor. He's a very polished coach that will be a guy that's going to get on a guy, but he's going to love him up. He's going to get to know those players so well. You know, there's nothing totally different that you'd say, boy, we're a different coverage, we're a different pressure team. He's just been a great leader, and his leadership style is different than mine. It's different than what Coach Hazelton was, and when I replaced Scottie, and it's really meshed and worked well with our guys."
They're similar yet different defenses, but both championship-level.