this guy is terrible, 20 yard out, he bounces pass 20 feet short of receiver. Then runs around wasting time, getting sacked on second & third down, gets 0 points.:mj07: :mj07: *:scared :scared :com:
lol lol it never changes, Mcnabb absolutely sux
- Thread starter shamrock
- Start date
You have TO in one corner and McNabb in the other, I'd vote McNabb the better person, smarter player and team player hands down!
im a lil sensitive b/c I have always liked Mac so much, but if he is so gawd awful as so many like to say, who besides PM, Brady, Favre (all HOFs) have been better over last 7 years? I mean, to a lot of guys everyone sux, and if thats true, are peyton, BF, and Brady the only good ones outta 32 teams, but I hear guys slam Favre and Peyton all the time, too; even brady looked human w/o wrs in the Bronco game ... So please list all the great ones so I can be informed :shrug:
mcabb killed it tonight... 2tds passing and rushing on MNF... imagine if westbrook played, you knows hes not gonna fumble twice in the redzone... shamrock you spoke to soon, go hide
Let me see if I can dig up the thread from last season when he was hurt, some people were trying to argue that McNabb was not one of the 20 best QB's in the NFL today. Somebody even had Aaron Brooks ahead of him if I remember correctly.
I'll admit readily that I'm as big of an Eagles' homer as it gets, but come on, his performance must carry some weight.
http://www.madjacksports.com/forum/showthread.php?t=211743&page=2&highlight=McNabb+list
Was wrong about Brooks but a poster had McNabb ranked 18th in the league.
Putting David Carr and his handful of lifetime wins eight spots in front of him is pretty funny though.
Looking at my own list from a year ago I am embarrassed to have Culpepper in the top ten, boy has he fallen :sadwave:
Was wrong about Brooks but a poster had McNabb ranked 18th in the league.
Putting David Carr and his handful of lifetime wins eight spots in front of him is pretty funny though.
Looking at my own list from a year ago I am embarrassed to have Culpepper in the top ten, boy has he fallen :sadwave:
thanx blackman
he did get his team to some nfc finals and a SB, he did win an MVP; one racist poster who seems to be in hiding this year used to insist Mac was no good b/c he was black/i.e. no mechanics and only a running qb ... course he used those arugments on every black qb too ... love to see him deny it since i kept some of his IMs insisting this :nono:
sorry, to dredge that up but sometimes people learn their lesson when spanked in public and one less racist knucklehead in the world is fine by me
he did get his team to some nfc finals and a SB, he did win an MVP; one racist poster who seems to be in hiding this year used to insist Mac was no good b/c he was black/i.e. no mechanics and only a running qb ... course he used those arugments on every black qb too ... love to see him deny it since i kept some of his IMs insisting this :nono:
sorry, to dredge that up but sometimes people learn their lesson when spanked in public and one less racist knucklehead in the world is fine by me
He did an OK job tonight,Maybe I'm wrong but he does tend to throw short an low skipping the ball and he can't throw worth a fu ck on the run:com: IMO..... Will c
They did play the Packers not the 85 Bears....
Mcnabb is an above average QB.. nothing more..
Oh.. Brady, Manning, Roethisberger, Heck Mcnair is better.. Leftwitch (ok Im pushing it).. Delhomme, Hasselback..Green.. Bledsoe.. (better arm and head) Brady Quinn, Aaron Brooks.. (Just seeing if your still paying attention).. Brees...Brunell..
Mcnabb is an above average QB.. nothing more..
Oh.. Brady, Manning, Roethisberger, Heck Mcnair is better.. Leftwitch (ok Im pushing it).. Delhomme, Hasselback..Green.. Bledsoe.. (better arm and head) Brady Quinn, Aaron Brooks.. (Just seeing if your still paying attention).. Brees...Brunell..
That is a problem, loves to hit people in the feet. His release point can often be very late and the skips the ball to it's intended target.
All and all he runs the west coast offense very well.
Name a quarterback who does more with less. Had a bad 1st half throwing, but he's still one of the elite quarterbacks in the league.
ok guys, admittedly he had a better second half, but he had to,.First half was atrocious. And again in second half taking 2 sacks took them out of field goal position. That was 2 drives he himself killed getting 0 points with first down on the 20, if it wasn't the Packers, he would have cost them the game, just like last year Monday night against Dallas, when he threw a interception for Dallas touchdown when Philly had the game won, inexplicable!
If Packer cb CARROLL, was not on the field, second half would have been a little different I suspect. Lewis has 1 touchdown in 4 seasons, then gets 2 in 3 plays with Carroll covering him. Let's see how he performs next week against a decent defensive team.
If Packer cb CARROLL, was not on the field, second half would have been a little different I suspect. Lewis has 1 touchdown in 4 seasons, then gets 2 in 3 plays with Carroll covering him. Let's see how he performs next week against a decent defensive team.
