Who says the "small stuff" should be on us, Mags? Maybe $1000 is small stuff to you but it's not to a lot of people.Really? Wow.
To protect you from a life changing illness or event. Say a bad car accident. Say breaking your leg skiing. In either case, bills could run $25-$30K.
It is a relief only paying $1,000 out of pocket in that case.
The small stuff - that should be on us. If you want all the maintenance stuff covered, then you'll just pay a much higher premium.
Pretty simple stuff. Imagine how much your car insurance would be if they had to pay for car washes, oil and filter changes, brakes, etc......
Insurance, by definition, is to cover UNEXPECTED events, not routine day to day expenses that one can reasonably budget for.
You're equating health insurance to car insurance? I've gotta wonder why my employer doesn't provide me with car insurance then? Or why the government doesn't provide me with car insurance when I turn 65? Maybe it's because one is a necessity of life and the other is not? Sure, there are those who roll the dice but it's because they know if they're in a car accident tomorrow, the EMT's and ER doctors aren't going to let them bleed to death because they don't have insurance.
Civilized societies take care of their people.