trade advice

[NIEM36]

Ok, this is my team, and I feel that i need another running back. Below is the trade proposed to me.
What do you think I should do.

Player YTD Pts Bye
Palmer, Carson CIN QB (P) 90.00 8
Warner, Kurt ARI QB (P) 78.25 4
McGahee, Willis BAL RB 74.70 7
Parker, Willie PIT RB (Q) 30.30 8
Rice, Ray BAL RB 94.20 7
Tomlinson, LaDainian SDC RB (P) 14.00 5
Edwards, Braylon NYJ WR 41.30 9
Holmes, Santonio PIT WR 63.10 8
Mason, Derrick BAL WR 61.40 7
Smith, Steve CAR WR 47.90 4
Smith, Steve NYG WR 109.10 10
Davis, Vernon SFO TE 66.20 6
Miller, Heath PIT TE 70.50 8
Reed, Jeff PIT PK 27.00 8
Bears, Chicago CHI Def 50.00 5
Dolphins, Miami MIA Def 48.00 6
16 Total Players


Proposed trade:
I give up:
McGahee, Willis BAL RB
Holmes, Santonio PIT WR
Smith, Steve CAR WR

And get:
Benson, Cedric CIN RB
Berrian, Bernard MIN WR
Bowe, Dwayne KCC WR

 

[Randercity]

Make the trade....

BENSON will get his carries EVERY week PERIOD. No guarantee with McGahee.


Berrian is the most targeted receiver on MINNY and once they start playing some good teams, they will need to throw it even more when they're trailing. Steve Smith has nobody to throw him the ball this year, and no change on the horizon.

BOWE could get traded to BALT, or somewhere else like CHI where he would have a good young QB to get him the ball. Holmes hasn't impressed much this year, and with Mike Wallace stepping up, he's now the main deep threat for PITT

make the trade and don't look back! :SIB

 

[taoist]

I hope you made this trade....


Steve Smith is killing me this year in one of my leagues.... kurby

 

[NIEM36]

i made the trade.