Chris, I swear I didn't try to start something up this time
Here is all I was saying. Since I started playing baseball I have always used 3+ books. I have used VIP, Wagerstreet, Pinnacle, GCS, 365, Canbet (not a sponsor), SIA (not a sponsor), Alladin's Gold (defunct), Infinity, GameDay, WSEX and Carib to bet on baseball at different times. I may have used CRIS or Olympic as well but I don't think so because of the 20 cent lines.
I have always shopped around actively for the best lines (I play almost exclusively dogs) and I have done very well overall. The one book that I have never made a profit at, and in fact never even made a withdrawl from, is Pinnacle. I don't use line movement to handicap. I merely use my own methods, find a game I like and then look for the best line. For whatever reason, Pinnacle always beat the crap out of me because the vast majority of the time that I found the best line at their book, it ended up being a loser.
Now, I know this defies logic. If I am really that scared of Pinnacle, shouldn't I pass any game where they offer the best line? If I am not scared, why wouldn't I have them as a steady shop when they offer 8 cent lines?
My only response is that I choose the "Ostrich" method as it regards Pinnacle. I simply avoid looking at their lines so that my handicapping stays pure.
Maybe it is some great mental block that is keeping me from winning at Pinnacle. Maybe. Obviously Mr. states that he has had great success over a few months betting there. But I can tell you that I am not the only good handicapper to get beat by Pinnacle. And I can tell you that nothing in this industry is given out for free.
Ask yourself how a book that offers 8 cent baseball lines and 10 cent basketball and hockey lines can not only stay in business, but remain arguably the top book offshore? Part of it is not giving those perks to "sharp" players, to be sure, but something tells me that another part of it is staying ahead of the handicappers and making sure that their lines are on the right side more often than not.
Now, all that having been said, if I were the casual player looking to fund only a single book, I may very well choose Pinnacle. I mean, how can you pass up such low vig? Obviously they can be beat in that situation because IE is keeping a running bankroll on his page based on wagers at Pinnacle and he is in plus money.