Which one?

Which one?


  • Total voters
    26

The Joker

Registered
Forum Member
Aug 3, 2008
28,116
358
83
46
Tennessee
www.madjacksports.com
pizza_deep.jpg


main-qimg-796ca924c43da9eaa6bfade7f1d79d6f-c
 

johnnyonthespot

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 6, 2002
1,459
18
38
45
Cottonwood Heights, UT
I know it's not the question that was asked, but speaking as a native Chicagoan for the first 36 years of my life - when we say "Chicago pizza" we are not talking about deep dish. We're talking about the below - thin crust cut into squares. Deep dish is our "tourist pizza".

Don't get me wrong - I am not knocking deep dish. I love it. But your average Chicagoan has deep dish maybe 3-4 times/year. Thin crust is multiple times/month.

our-authentic-chicago.jpg
 

WhatsHisNuts

Woke
Forum Member
Aug 29, 2006
27,490
958
113
49
Earth
www.ffrf.org
I know it's not the question that was asked, but speaking as a native Chicagoan for the first 36 years of my life - when we say "Chicago pizza" we are not talking about deep dish. We're talking about the below - thin crust cut into squares. Deep dish is our "tourist pizza".

Don't get me wrong - I am not knocking deep dish. I love it. But your average Chicagoan has deep dish maybe 3-4 times/year. Thin crust is multiple times/month.

View attachment 10655

This is the same crap that everyone eats here in Columbus. It sucks. Donato's is the main local chain for this and I just don't get it.
 

johnnyonthespot

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 6, 2002
1,459
18
38
45
Cottonwood Heights, UT
This is the same crap that everyone eats here in Columbus. It sucks. Donato's is the main local chain for this and I just don't get it.

Order one in Chicago and then tell me it's the same. I guarantee it's not. There are plenty of places outside of Chicago that also advertise "deep dish" and that's also not the same. Gotta get the real thing!

If you don't frequent Chicago - there are three Chicago chains currently operating in Vegas: Rosati's, Aurelio's, and Giordano's. Rosati's and Aurelio's have great thin crust. I can personally vouch that the Aurelio's in Vegas is legit - although they are a little bit outside the norm as they use a hint of cheddar and a slightly sweet sauce that I love but some people hate. Giordano's I can also vouch for - you can't go wrong as they have both great thin and deep dish. They are in the shops right in front of Bally's and also have a location in the Summerlin area. Never had Rosati's there (probably because after hitting up the first two on my list that's enough pizza for one trip). It's good in Chicago but I'm a little leery outside of there because the original owner's 5 sons took over in the mid-90s and franchised the hell out of it. Usually when that happens the quality suffers.
 

Betone

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 24, 2004
16,247
274
83
65
Monument, CO
Order one in Chicago and then tell me it's the same. I guarantee it's not. There are plenty of places outside of Chicago that also advertise "deep dish" and that's also not the same. Gotta get the real thing!

If you don't frequent Chicago - there are three Chicago chains currently operating in Vegas: Rosati's, Aurelio's, and Giordano's. Rosati's and Aurelio's have great thin crust. I can personally vouch that the Aurelio's in Vegas is legit - although they are a little bit outside the norm as they use a hint of cheddar and a slightly sweet sauce that I love but some people hate. Giordano's I can also vouch for - you can't go wrong as they have both great thin and deep dish. They are in the shops right in front of Bally's and also have a location in the Summerlin area. Never had Rosati's there (probably because after hitting up the first two on my list that's enough pizza for one trip). It's good in Chicago but I'm a little leery outside of there because the original owner's 5 sons took over in the mid-90s and franchised the hell out of it. Usually when that happens the quality suffers.
Old Chicago is good in Colorado......... Not as detailed oriented as you, but it's good to me at least. :0008
And thin crust is the best for me.....JMO
 

redsfann

ale connoisseur
Forum Member
Aug 3, 1999
9,006
218
63
60
Somewhere in Corn Country
I know it's not the question that was asked, but speaking as a native Chicagoan for the first 36 years of my life - when we say "Chicago pizza" we are not talking about deep dish. We're talking about the below - thin crust cut into squares. Deep dish is our "tourist pizza".

Don't get me wrong - I am not knocking deep dish. I love it. But your average Chicagoan has deep dish maybe 3-4 times/year. Thin crust is multiple times/month.

View attachment 10655

You live in the city or a suburb? Brother lived in Downers Grove and I have a cousin that lives in Lincoln Park.

And gimme that top pie? love me some well made deep dish pizza


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

johnnyonthespot

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 6, 2002
1,459
18
38
45
Cottonwood Heights, UT
You live in the city or a suburb? Brother lived in Downers Grove and I have a cousin that lives in Lincoln Park.

And gimme that top pie? love me some well made deep dish pizza


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I kinda lived all over. Mostly in the western suburbs - grew up in Glen Ellyn and lived in Naperville (right next to Downers) for the last 6 years before before moving out to Utah in 2015. Dad still lives in Tinley Park. I did live in the city for a bit - Lincoln Park and Gold Coast for a year each. Chicago pizza is often on my mind as it's a pizza wasteland out here. Lou Malnati's and Giordano's both ship frozen deep dish out here so I always have a supply in my freezer but I just can't get a good thin crust anywhere.

And to answer your other question - Detroit style is a thick pan pizza cut into squares. Also referred to as Sicilian style. If you have a Jet's Pizza in your area - they're a chain that does that style.
 

redsfann

ale connoisseur
Forum Member
Aug 3, 1999
9,006
218
63
60
Somewhere in Corn Country
Which one?

I kinda lived all over. Mostly in the western suburbs - grew up in Glen Ellyn and lived in Naperville (right next to Downers) for the last 6 years before before moving out to Utah in 2015. Dad still lives in Tinley Park. I did live in the city for a bit - Lincoln Park and Gold Coast for a year each. Chicago pizza is often on my mind as it's a pizza wasteland out here. Lou Malnati's and Giordano's both ship frozen deep dish out here so I always have a supply in my freezer but I just can't get a good thin crust anywhere.

And to answer your other question - Detroit style is a thick pan pizza cut into squares. Also referred to as Sicilian style. If you have a Jet's Pizza in your area - they're a chain that does that style.

Only thing I know about Tinley Park is the outdoor music theater? what?s it called these days?
I?ve seen a few shows there but none recently.
I know Sicilian style pie, didn?t know it was also called Detroit style.
I?m in rural Iowa? the pizza here is tomato sauce on cardboard? fucking gross.
We try and hit up Lou Malnati?s every time we are in the area.
Iowa city is an hour away and there are several high quality pizza places there. Lived there for 15 years and still have many friends so I try and talk them into grabbing pizza when I?m over that way.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top