Former NFL Defensive Player of the Year, James Harrison says....

JT

Degenerate
Forum Member
Mar 28, 2000
3,592
81
48
60
Ventura, Ca.
I tried for a promotion at work and didn't get it. A department head needled me about getting a participation trophy. I got a good laugh when he gave me a fake rooster.

:0003
 

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
My kids aren't interested in participation trophies. They do not attend practice seeking a trophy, they do it because they enjoy it.


I'm not aware of any kid who joins a team to just get a trophy. If true that kid needs some help. I played baseball, hockey & a little football from 10 yrs. old till I was 20 & really hated practice I just wanted to play actual game. But to be a starter I had to practice . I don't remember getting a trophy or certificate for playing on a team, made any negative or thinking I deserved it. You & the Harrison's of the world are making way to much of this plus you don't give kids much credit to know the difference between participating & winning a championship.

I am not in Harrisons camp. Sure, I think participation awards are silly, but I don't take them away from my children. While I am discussing the issue, I most certainly not making a big deal about it.
 

sushi

Loopis
Forum Member
Dec 3, 2014
1,509
27
0
Hooters
You don't just show up to school and receive an a for participating. ... you have to work for the a
 

The Mover

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 22, 2000
3,998
47
0
Detroit,Mi
I am not in Harrisons camp. Sure, I think participation awards are silly, but I don't take them away from my children. While I am discussing the issue, I most certainly not making a big deal about it.

I apologize for putting you in the same camp. Have a good day.
 

Sportsaholic

Jack's Mentor
Forum Member
Jan 18, 2000
32,345
314
0
62
Crustacean Nation
My son is not a great athlete, never has been never will be.....he's loves to play and be a part of the team/process, he just doesn't have that competitive edge that's needed to be successful in sports.....While I'm not a fan of Trophies for all I do know it means the world to him that he played and was recognized for that...so with that I'm fine with it......:0008
 

Keyser Soze

Registered User
Forum Member
Jan 20, 2000
2,276
56
48
Orlando
C'mon! Since the beginning of time we have had sports. You can't have sports without teams. You can't have teams without some of the guys sucking, but they're still part of the team. Recognition?!?!?!?!!??!

Your recognition is that we let you wear the uniform. We give you a schedule so you can attend every game. And guess what? At some point during the year we all kneel down in the dirt and put on a big cheesy smile and have our picture taken as a TEAM. There's your friggin' participation trophy. If you simply get a trophy for merely showing up, what incentive do you have to get any better, or practice on your own?

This whole country is becoming so pussified that it's all a big joke.

Lastly, to all of the guys asking the question as to what you tell your kid when he brings home the bullshit participation trophy. There in lies part of the problem. You don't wait until it happens, because you are all well aware that they are going to be handed out at the end of the year to begin with. If you explain to them that thy're a friggin' joke to make one lazy right out of the gate, maybe, just maybe, you might get a little more drive or effort out of them wanting to make Pop's proud, or at the very least take some pride in their own performance.

It doesn't matter. This is just like politics. Nobody is going to change anyone's mind because of something they wrote on a message board, because they automatically perceive them to be the enemy from the jump.

Good luck dealing with the entitled little Dez Bryants as they get older and continue to expect that and even more. Just ask Mark Cuban.
 

fatdaddycool

Chi-TownHustler
Forum Member
Mar 26, 2001
13,698
263
83
60
Fort Worth TX usa
Yet most will attend graduation ceremonies for kindergarten, sixth grade, high school, and college. You'll congratulate your kids or buy them a car for a participation award. You'll give them a few bucks for losing a tooth, taking out the trash. You'll tell yourself they need a cell phone at ten years old, you'll buy them the latest fashion for back to school clothes and supplies. They get ice cream cones because they only screamed a little at seeing saint when they got to the dentist office. Video games for birthdays.

Nah, nobody does participation trophies.



Whatever.




Hope this helps,
FDC
 

MadJack

Administrator
Staff member
Forum Admin
Super Moderators
Channel Owner
Jul 13, 1999
104,685
1,353
113
69
home
Yet most will attend graduation ceremonies for kindergarten, sixth grade, high school, and college. You'll congratulate your kids or buy them a car for a participation award. You'll give them a few bucks for losing a tooth, taking out the trash. You'll tell yourself they need a cell phone at ten years old, you'll buy them the latest fashion for back to school clothes and supplies. They get ice cream cones because they only screamed a little at seeing saint when they got to the dentist office. Video games for birthdays.

Nah, nobody does participation trophies.



Whatever.




Hope this helps,
FDC

Wow. Calm down bud. :0003
 

SixFive

bonswa
Forum Member
Mar 12, 2001
18,721
237
63
53
BG, KY, USA
I was on many shitty teams when I was a kid, and it just makes me work harder because I wanted win. I dribbled that ball around the block left handed,then right handed, then I shot hundreds of free throws and 3 pointers. It was hard for me to be competitive like I was and lose. If I received a participation award or trophy after getting pummeled by 30, I would have taken it as a slap in the face.

Same thing applies now as I'm still hugely competitive, but since I'm getting too old to play sports, I have gravitated to poker like many athletes do. I have read books, practiced, watched, and done all I could to become a better player. If I'm in a tournament and bust on the bubble, I don't want a certificate congratulating me on being the last not to make money, right?

Anyway, all that aside, I think participation awards are ok sometimes, but I think children should be taught to strive to always do their best and work hard in sports, at work, as people, and in life in general. Participation awards can make for good teachable moments. I would never take one away from a child though who is proud of it nor would I ever try to diminish its value. I would and I have use it as teaching tool.
 

BobbyBlueChip

Trustee
Forum Member
Dec 27, 2000
20,704
285
83
53
Belly of the Beast
My daughter lost in the championship game and when she showed me her second place trophy, it pissed me off how proud she was. So I grabbed it out of her hand, broke it in half over the rim of my new G550 and said "Second place?!? That's first loser" and then let her know that her and her teammate could walk home.
 

Betone

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 24, 2004
16,253
278
83
65
Monument, CO
My daughter lost in the championship game and when she showed me her second place trophy, it pissed me off how proud she was. So I grabbed it out of her hand, broke it in half over the rim of my new G550 and said "Second place?!? That's first loser" and then let her know that her and her teammate could walk home.

:lol:
 

fatdaddycool

Chi-TownHustler
Forum Member
Mar 26, 2001
13,698
263
83
60
Fort Worth TX usa
My daughter lost in the championship game and when she showed me her second place trophy, it pissed me off how proud she was. So I grabbed it out of her hand, broke it in half over the rim of my new G550 and said "Second place?!? That's first loser" and then let her know that her and her teammate could walk home.
Ha!


My ex-mother in law use to get a ride to Crawfordsville from Alamo to play bingo on Friday nights. One time she won something like $200. She was all happy about it. My exes extended family all came over and camped by the creek. Had a bonfire, food, beer, live music jam in the woods. They had banjos, fiddles, accordion, was awesome. Next morning my ex-mother in law's money was gone but there was a nice thank you card in her purse that said, "Thanks for the party and congratulations on winning at bingo! Ya can't win If'n ya don't play".



Hope this helps,
FDC
 

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
Hard to imagine a grown man taking trophies away from his children, but this isn't the first time JH has proven he lacks class. Many agree with his point on participation trophies, but I haven't heard a single person agree with his actions

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top