We all know Ohio St. has the edge in:
Coaching - Jim Tressel versus Mack Brown, who is obviously John Cooper's long lost brother
Linebackers - Hawk, Carpenter, Schlaigel have the capabilities and talents to contain Vince Young
Home Field - I would put "under the lights at the 'Shoe" against any hostile college football environment in the country as THE toughest place to play
Texas has the edge in:
Quarterback - Vince Young is hyped up as the best non-pocket passing QB in the country, and basically second only to Leinart. Simply put, he is SICK
Talent - The seniors in this game were ranked as the #1 recruiting class in the nation four years ago, and Mack Brown has kept his recruiting excellence going since then, stacking his team with dominating athleticism.
Both teams have excellent Defenses. The Buckeyes have extremely talented safteys and cornerbacks, the D-Line is solid, and we all know about the Linebackers. Texas has an excellent secondary that will jump at any mistake Zwick/Smith may make.
Texas has the more high powered offense with an all-american QB and a talented corp of running backs. They are lacking somewhat with receivers though, and I'm curious to know why, if Sneed is Ted Ginn-like, Texas only got him the ball one time the whole game. The Buckeyes "spread-like" offense will favor the pass this year with young RBs in the back field. Texas will have some match-up problems with OSU's group of receivers and tight ends. With 4 returning O-Lineman and Tony Pittman's skill, the run game cannot be overlooked.
Plain and simple, this game will end up being very close. My guess is the game will be within a FG, which leads me to a factor that is being greatly overlooked...the KICKING game
I tried reading everyone's post, and I may have missed this key point, but Texas missed 3 extra points last week (and used two different kickers) McGee missed the first, and had two others blocked. Texas did not attempt and extra point.
Mike Nugent graduated last year and is now with the Jets, so the Bucks have turned to Josh Huston. Unlike McGee, Huston looked unwavering agianst Miami, oh, converting 4 extra points, making 2 FGs, and kicking all but two kickoffs out of the endzone.
My best guess is that this game comes down to a late score, possibly a TD, but more likely a FG. My lean is with the Buckeyes, as coaching, home field advantage, and any resemblance of a kicking game are huge in this situation. I'll probably lay off this game, as attending the game will be action enough for me.