Posted on Tue, Nov. 23, 2004
'It makes no sense'
As sixth hunter dies, sheriff offers details in attack, but motive remains unknown
BY TIM NELSON and KEVIN HARTER
Pioneer Press
Updated 12:07 p.m., Tuesday, Nov. 23, 2004
HAYWARD, Wis. ? The scene is as old as humanity itself: A hunter stakes out territory, only to find it claimed by another. Modern deer hunters usually resolve the matter amicably.
But deep in a thick Wisconsin forest on Sunday, for reasons authorities still can't fathom, a St. Paul man who was asked to leave another hunter's deer stand began to do so and then turned and opened fire on one of the landowners and his fellow hunters, killing six and wounding two, authorities said. The suspect had apparently gotten lost earlier that morning and wound up on the private property.
The victims were all from the Rice Lake area of northwestern Wisconsin. The dead were identified as Robert Crotteau, 42; his 20-year-old son, Joey Crotteau; Al Laski, 43; Mark Roidt, 28; Dennis Drew, 55; and Jessica Willers, 27, daughter of Terry Willers, one of the landowners, who was also shot.
Five were killed on Sunday. Drew, who was shot in the abdomen, died early Monday evening at St. Joseph's Hospital in Marshfield, where he had been flown at 5:15 p.m. Monday from Lakeview Medical Center in Rice Lake.
Authorities said Terry Willers was the first one shot, and his daughter and Laski were shot and killed when they came to his aid. As other members of the hunting party ? which numbered 14 or 15 in total ? rushed to the scene from a hunting shack a quarter-mile away, they were picked off, too.
Some of the victims were shot more than once, authorities said.
The suspected assailant was identified as Chai Soua Vang, 36, a St. Paul truck driver. Sawyer County Sheriff James Meier said he was perplexed over why the suspect allegedly opened fire on the other hunters 90 miles northeast of the Twin Cities.
"It makes no sense," the sheriff said. The suspect, he said, "speaks fluent English. He's educated. He's an American citizen."
Chai Soua Vang, who is married and the father of six, will probably have his first court appearance today, Meier said. It will be a probable-cause hearing, where a judge decides whether there is cause to hold him. He has not been charged.
Chai Soua Vang's younger brother arrived in the Sawyer County seat of Hayward on Monday with hopes of getting in to see his jailed sibling. Sang Vang, 32, said his brother was an occasional hunter, and he couldn't believe he could be involved in such a violent outburst.
"I don't know what to think. I'm shocked," said Sang Vang. He said when his mother called him to tell him about his brother's arrest, he thought it was a dream. "I just wanted to wake up. I'm still so very shocked."
Sang Vang said his brother came to this country from their native Laos in 1980. He said Chai Soua Vang was "a good family man," who served in the U.S. Army.
"He's always been a nice brother to me," he said. "I don't know what happened."
A game warden apprehended Chai Soua Vang about five hours after the shooting. He offered no resistance, and Meier said the suspect has "shown a willingness to cooperate."
Asked about the suspect's demeanor, Meier said he was "extremely calm." And what did the sheriff think about that?
"I find it frightening," he replied.
Drew's family issued a statement Monday evening expressing sadness at his death and "requesting privacy as they deal with this very public tragedy."
Drew's brother-in-law, Lauren Hesebeck, 48, was released Monday evening from the Rice Lake hospital after sustaining a gunshot wound to his left shoulder. Terry Willers, 47, was shot in the neck and flown to the Marshfield hospital, where he was in fair condition Monday evening, according to a nursing supervisor.
Dr. Lynn Koob, a surgeon at Lakeview Medical Center, said it appeared that Drew, Hesebeck and Willers had been wounded by a "high-powered weapon" fired from "reasonably close range." When Chai Soua Vang was apprehended, he was carrying an SKS semiautomatic carbine, a rifle that traces its origin to the Soviet Union nearly 60 years ago and also has been mass-produced by the Chinese.
Chai Soua Vang's weapon carried a 20-round clip. Authorities said it was empty when he was taken into custody.
As state and federal investigators converged on the remote area to search for evidence and question witnesses, Meier said there was still much to figure out. But investigators said it appears the series of events that led to the shooting began Sunday morning when Chai Soua Vang ? who had apparently come to the area to hunt with two or three other as-yet-unidentified hunters ? got lost in the thick woods.